John Healey has said, in advance of the Budget, that his plan is to help the UK through what he describes as a “difficult moment”. His plan is to help businesses, entrepreneurs and households.
He has already announced measures he says will help with the cost of living, including removing tariffs on some foodstuffs, which, it is suggested, could save the average household around £20 a year. If there is one thing that today is going to prove, it is that John Healey is a man who sweats the small stuff.
He has, however, no choice but to do that because he has already said his approach will “do all this responsibly, sticking with tight fiscal rules.”
The word “responsibly” is doing a lot of work in that sentence. To define responsibility, you have to know your priorities. In this case, by linking the word with fiscal rules, John Healey gives the clearest possible indication of those to whom he thinks he is responsible. And unambiguously, that is the City of London and the bond market.
The fact that, as I demonstrate in this morning's video using data from the supermarket chain Asda and the Centre for Economics and Business Research, 20% of the UK's population is living in poverty, unable to meet their basic needs, and another 40% of the population have very little spare income to offer very much flexibility in life, suggests quite clearly how wrong his definition of responsibility is.
When at least half the UK population is struggling, maintaining the fiscal rules and patterns of behaviour that keep this situation intact represents gross irresponsibility.
It also reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of the relationships of power in the UK. If more than half our population struggle to afford the lifestyle which they are told by our advertising industry that they should aspire to, without any prospect of doing so, with the consequent resentment that follows from that, and at least 40% of our population struggle to simply make ends meet, the responsibility of any Chancellor is to these people above all else.
In this situation, a Chancellor has no duty to the wealthy. Nor do they owe a duty to the bond markets, where the wealthy deposit funds with the government that they have no use for at present. Instead, they have a duty to those without funds, without enough income, and without hope.
I know John Healey will fail today, and he will do so simply because he cannot work out to whom he is responsible. This basic ethical test is apparently beyond a Labour Chancellor of the Exchequer's ability to answer correctly.
If you want to know how far the neoliberal economics of austerity have corroded this country's politics, that simple fact provides all the evidence you need.
It is time for an economics of hope that puts government on the side of the people who need its help to achieve what would otherwise be impossible in their lives.
Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:
There are links to this blog's glossary in the above post that explain technical terms used in it. Follow them for more explanations.
You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.
And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:

Buy me a coffee!

“tight fiscal rules”
“responsible”
“difficult”
“£20/yr help with cost of living”
Here we go again. Neo-Reevesism, neo-Starmerism, neo-change, neo-austerity, neo-toxic-outcomes for millions of the neo-vulnerable.
As Theres May used to say, “Nothing has changed”.
On that, she was right
Well said!
I’ll add “responsible” to my lexicon of government doublespeak, alongside “pragmatic” (it’s “responsible” to let children go malnourished, so long as the bond traders get paid; it’s “pragmatic” to let the planet burn, so long as the fossil fuel companies get paid)
Agreed
Healy is a utilitarian. Small increments here and there will benefit society is his moto. British politicians talk about “pragmatism” very different to Americans. He is thinking in terms of utility and believes this is to be pragmatic and an easy win. America is where pragmatism comes from. NASA went to the moon because it is hard. It demonstrated to the American public that hard does not make something impossible. That is a pragmatic reason. We are going to make families £20 better off because everything else is irresponsible is a utilitarian speaking.
If anything takes your breath away these days, its the lack of ambition in the face of crises, isn’t it?
My view – there has been a coup in this country through the political system by advocates of Neo-liberalism that has led to the fiscal power of the state being put to the use increasingly of corporate and financial industry interests.
Healey knows who his Daddy is in my view and accepts the system as it is. Changing anything to him is too much hard work. He is not innocent at all.
Martin Lewis in this short video today says he has just come from a meeting with the Chancellor. If he has the Chancellor’s ear, is he someone to try to talk to about MMT? https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/videos/c60qk90dd980o
He is intensely micro.
MMT is macro.
Watching Sky News this morning and various people commenting on the budget, I have a question. Is is it genuine ignorance of the problems facing the U.K, or are we being deliberately lied to in order to prevent people making informed judgements?
They think privilege defines what worries people – because the wealthy are the people they meet.
Thinking about the misinformation surrounding the way the UK economy works and how democracy is affected, I came to the conclusion that most of this is deliberate. We have a population who are supposed to be sufficiently well informed to be able to choose through the ballot the sort of government they want. But there is no formal education at any level that makes certain that they are well informed and yet it is compulsory in schools to learn the algebra, geometry and trigonometry, useful of course but not essential in many walks of life.
He hello Richard I appreciate you articles very much as I don’t really know a lot about economics and you y break it down very thoughtfully. I would be interested in what you make of the radio 4 programs in the Understand series – “The Growth Conundrum” (3 episodes) – in which Poland is held up as an example to ponder. Sorry for my typos
Thank you for your kind comments, and please don’t worry about the typos.
I haven’t listened to those programmes, so I can’t offer a fair assessment of their arguments or how they present Poland.
What I would say is that economic growth is not an end in itself. The questions that interest me are who benefits from growth, whether it improves public services and living standards, and whether it is environmentally sustainable.
Poland’s economic experience is certainly worth examining, but we need to understand what has driven its growth and how the benefits have been distributed before drawing conclusions.
I will try to find time to listen.