I wrote the articles I share for the second time on this blog this morning in May, when Alan Milburn, the former Labour health secretary from the Brown/Blair era, produced his first-stage report on solving what the current Labour government defines to be the problem of young people not in employment, education or training (NEETs).
The articles can be found here, and here.
Nothing has changed with regard to what I have to say since May.
The Bank of England is still pursuing a policy of deliberately creating unemployment in the UK to supposedly control inflation, although there is no credible relationship between higher unemployment and bringing inflation caused by external price shocks under control.
And nothing has been done to change the work environment for young people with disabilities or neurocomplexity, or the support that they might need that they were offered when at school, the need for which has miraculously disappeared by the time they reach their 20s.
Because of that, I can say for certain that today's report from Alan Milburn is an exercise in what I describe as ‘othering', which is a process of pointing fingers at those in society whom those with power would like to blame for the supposed problems facing the economy, but which those being blamed did nothing to create.
As many who are old enough to recall might be aware, there was a meme just after the 2008 financial crash, and the associated onset of austerity under George Osborne, that blamed the excessive cost of librarians in Wolverhampton for the UK economy crashing. That meme was, of course, ridiculous.
Today's report from Alan Milburn is going to be equally ridiculous. It is based on the premise that young people in this country, for whom the neoliberal system of economic organisation that we now have within the workplace can provide no employment, are the people to blame for the supposed financial crisis that this country faces. This is despite the fact that there is no crisis with social security costs in this country, and no crisis with regard to our capacity to fund the government, now or into the future, as I keep on pointing out.
We do, however, face multiple very real crises.
The first is a crisis of neoliberalism. It has failed. Its toxic approach to people in society is the fundamental cause of the problems that we face. The sooner we recognise this, and stop trying to force people to adapt to its demands, and instead create a society that cares, the better off we will be.
Second, we face a crisis of comprehension amongst economists, the Treasury, politicians and commentators who collectively believe that money is an exogenous variable within the economy, provided by the private sector to the government so that it might spend, when in fact it is only by government action that the money in question exists, is in circulation, and can even be deposited with the government in the form of savings bonds. Incomprehension on this scale can only be described as a significant contributor to the crises that we face.
Third, we face a crisis of cruelty, and this is common to all our leading political parties who, without exception, are saying that we cannot afford to care. They deliberately renamed social security as welfare to excuse this cruelty. In the process, they are trying to give themselves cover when blaming those most vulnerable for failures that they have created, for which they are responsible, but for which they will not accept blame.
It is not young people who have failed this country, as Alan Milburn will implicitly claim today, with his report then being used by Andy Burnham as an excuse to punish them by withdrawing benefits they need. It is Burnham, Badenoch, Davey, and Farage who, with their neoliberal beliefs that demand victims to sacrifice, are failing young people and all those who care about them in this country.
Their systemic failure is collective, toxic, and unforgivable because it is chosen. That is why the whole lot of them deserve to be swept from office for good, for the crimes against society they commit in pursuit of their own gain.
Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:
There are links to this blog's glossary in the above post that explain technical terms used in it. Follow them for more explanations.
You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.
And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:

Buy me a coffee!

“Both neoliberalism and fascism depersonalise regular citizens, though they achieve this through opposite mechanisms. While neoliberalism isolates individuals by reducing them to purely economic actors, fascism erases individuality by absorbing citizens into a rigid collective mass.” (AI Overview)
Might our society be currently facing both types of danger?
Yes
It’s the big excuse to further salami slice the portrayal of the money supply as static because of the false issue of there being ‘no money’. So, the young have to pay again (they have to pay for their own professional further education already).
It is weird to think that we are seeing a bubble in action here – politicians and theory addled economists who exist in their own eco system and are cut off from reality – deracinated. It is the epitome of stupid to me.
‘Was at the dentist yesterday – the suction machine at the NHS dentists had broken down and the other surgeries were in use. So me and the dentist – a Pakistani – sat there and talked about the general enshittification of everything in the West and few other things too. I will have to return for my filling, but it was a really enjoyable conversation, one felt a level of connection and recognition that others can see what one can see. I felt a pang of hope.
Always good when that happens.
In my view it’s an exercise in deliberate deception: from the official figures which show the percentage of NEETs is no higher than in 2001 and lower than in 2011 to the emotionally manipulative language used to justify cuts (“This is about young people’s futures” “We risk a lost generation” “We don’t want to park people on benefits”) it really is sickening what they’re prepared to say.
I saw last night that Milburn is offering a “legal guarantee” of employment or training and promises public sector jobs will be created for young people. This I believe is designed to lure soft Left Labour MPs into accepting these proposals.
And again I have to say that I can’t help but be suspicious of agendas around conscription and authoritarian uses of the state at a time when the international situation is deteriorating ever further and neoliberalism is entering its final crisis.
I’ve just listened to Alan Milburn’s presentation of his review and I got no sense he was blaming young people for not being in education, employment or training. But maybe that’s just me.
So why is he punishing them then?
Did my comment about Badenoch on the other thread not make it past moderation?
Not yet
I was engaged
I am sometimes
Comments do then have to wait
That’s how the system works
Apologies Richard and thank you.
While MSM is flooding everywhere with this report. Our beloved government has decided to apply Moore’s Law
It’s a good day to bury bad news
In one of the early news bulletins during the Today programme it was mentioned that, Blairite, Yvette Cooper will not be taking advantage of the Palantir break clause.
Due to the early hour I thought I would check. Loads of links turned up on the first search page, some MSM but no BBC. I picked one that everybody could access.
MPs ask what the break clause was for as Palantir wins two more years in the NHS | The Register
https://www.theregister.com/public-sector/2026/11/17/mps-ask-what-the-break-clause-was-for-as-palantir-wins-two-more-years-in-the-nhs/5310348
Am I surprised. NO.
I am shocked.
Why the heck not?