When will modern monetary theory actually be put into practice? My answer is that politicians will adopt MMT when they desperately need an alternative to the economic ideas that have failed them.
History suggests that major changes in economic thinking happen during crises. Keynesian economics gained influence after the failures exposed by the Great Depression. The Beveridge Report helped prepare the foundations for the post-war settlement. Neoliberal thinkers were ready when the economic turmoil of the 1970s created their political opportunity.
The same happened after the 2008 financial crisis. Tax Justice campaigners had spent years developing arguments and practical reforms that suddenly became politically useful when governments needed answers.
MMT needs to be equally prepared. Importantly, I argue that MMT does not require us to invent a new monetary system. It describes how the existing system already works: government spending creates money, taxation removes money from circulation, and government bonds provide a savings mechanism.
The real change is therefore in how politicians understand and manage the economy. Instead of asking whether government can afford something, MMT asks whether we have the real resources required to deliver it.
A new hospital, for example, requires land, materials, builders, doctors, nurses and other staff. Money itself cannot create those resources. The challenge for government is to mobilise available resources while managing genuine shortages and inflationary pressures.
I believe another major economic crisis could force politicians to reconsider the economic assumptions they currently rely upon. Financial instability, war, AI, climate change or recession could provide that catalyst.
We should not want such a crisis. But if one comes, an alternative must already be available. MMT needs a clear, practical political narrative explaining what governments can actually do. When politicians need an economic life belt, MMT must be ready.
This is the audio version:
This infographic supports this video:

This is the transcript:
When will we get modern monetary theory, or MMT for short, in practice? That's a question I'm always asked, and my answer is that politicians will adopt MMT when they realise it offers the answer they need.
That recognition is unlikely to come in normal political times. Politicians always remain within their comfort zones whenever they can. They are human beings who like the status quo, as we can all see. So the catalyst for change will then be a crisis, and that is why preparation now, before a crisis finally hits us, matters so much. If we are to get MMT, we have to be ready for the possibility that politicians will need it, and I think they will.
Crises change economic thinking when old answers stop working.
Neoclassical economics failed during the 1930s. Keynesianism offered politics an alternative at that time.
The Beveridge Report of 1942 provided a plan for the post-war settlement and the creation of the welfare state. It was opportunistic in 1942. In 1945, it was desperately needed.
And let's be honest, Margaret Thatcher seized her opportunity when 1970s inflation discredited the existing Keynesian consensus of that moment, and she too created change as a result.
History suggests that crisis creates the space for economic change, and the financial crisis proved that point again in 2008. Gordon Brown, Barack Obama and the G20 needed explanations for what had gone wrong. The tax haven story that I had helped promote became part of that explanation, which they latched onto with enthusiasm. Tax justice campaigners like me had already prepared the proposals for reform that they then used.
It was not by chance that I was at the London G20 Summit in April 2009 asking Gordon Brown a question in front of 4,000 journalists. I was opportune as to the moment, to the potential to create change. Ideas that had previously seemed unlikely suddenly became politically useful. Many of the reforms we tax justice campaigners had demanded were then adopted.
The key point is, though, that the alternative must exist before politicians have realised that they need it. Keynes, Beveridge and neoliberal thinkers had all prepared ideas in advance. Tax justice campaigners had done the same before 2008. John Christensen and I had written our manifesto, and we had done the donkey work to have the tools available that we thought politicians would need.
None of these people could know exactly when their opportunity would come. They created the foundations for change without certainty of success, or knowing that their plan might even ever be needed, and MMT now needs to undertake the same preparation. That is my point.
Planning for that change is, however, possible. MMT has the opportunity, and it will be easy to do.
Vitally, modern monetary theory describes how modern monetary systems already operate. It does not require us to reinvent those systems. The monetary plumbing already works in the way that MMT describes.
The system itself does operate. We do know that government spending does already create money. We do know that taxes do take it back out of the economy and do not fund the government spending. We do know that bonds are savings mechanisms, and they also do not fund the government's spending. The necessary change that we need now is not in the financial system as such, but in the understanding of how it works and how it is managed. That is where our economists and our politicians, as well as our commentators, are all in denial.
The fact that the system will not, as such, need to change will make the transition to MMT thinking much easier than most people imagine.
But that doesn't mean to say there isn't work to do. MMT needs to have what I call "a better song to sing" by the time neoliberalism fails, and that may be soon. It must have all the necessary explanations as to what it can do, ready in advance. That is what that song is. It's the narrative that hangs everything together to say there is an alternative.
Politicians in a crisis will need an understandable alternative. We must have it. They will need to know what an MMT-managed economy would actually mean, and elaborate forecasts will not provide them with that political narrative. A practical explanation of what government can do will meet that need. This is the application of MMT that we need to develop now.
So we need to be able to explain the difference between asking the question: 'Can we resource it?', instead of 'Can we afford it?', and what the consequences will look like in practice, because that is the key change that MMT will deliver in practice.
A new hospital provides the obvious example. To build a new hospital, we don't go and look at a bank account and say, have we got the money? Instead, we have to go and ask, do we have the land, the materials, the builders and the architects? And then can we provide the doctors, the nurses, and all the other staff down to the porters who are required to staff the place? Only if those resources exist can the hospital be created. Money is not the fundamental constraint; resources are. That is the difference that MMT makes. MMT requires that we ask better questions.
So in the midst of the coming financial crisis, we must be ready to explain that money is not the big issue, even if everyone else thinks that it is. Resources are what will matter. It is resources that the government will have to direct so that it can deliver outcomes to overcome the problems that the crisis will create.
Government can always create money through its spending. That is a matter of fact. But that spending can bring unused, and most especially underutilised, resources, and there will be a great deal of those in the coming crisis, into productive use without necessarily creating the risk of inflation, whilst the existence of scarce resources may create inflationary pressure, but not if the process of change is properly managed, and that inflationary pressure in some areas is anticipated and change is made to manage it.
The objective will be to manage resources in a way that ensures that need is met and scarce resources are well used. That is the process that MMT enables, and that is critical. MMT is a process that does require better decision-making by our politicians. And at the time of crisis, there can be no greater need than better decision-making.
Politicians can still have their ambitions. They will still be able to make plans. MMT would encourage them to do so, particularly in a time of crisis. But what MMT shows is how those plans can actually be delivered. Resource management and inflation control become explicit parts of that decision process in a way that they aren't at present because micro-thinking about bank balances is all that matters. Artificial constraints will no longer dominate the discussion. Economic policy will become focused on what is physically and socially possible. That fact will be critical if, and I think when, we have another crash.
So, what could trigger this crisis that I'm talking about? I think you know the answers to that question.
Neoliberalism is already under severe pressure. We've done a video about that already this week.
Trump's economic policies could bring the world to its knees. His war could do the same thing.
An AI-driven financial collapse could provide another trigger point.
And so could the climate crisis. We are facing enormous stresses in the next year or two from drought, from floods, from fires, from El Niño, and that, of course, rolls on into food supply chains and water issues and everything else.
And the consequence of all of these things is that markets, banks and credit systems could again require government intervention for any of these reasons, and maybe all of them at the same time.
Recession and unemployment could then make existing policy impossible to defend. Neoliberalism would have failed. And in that situation, politicians will need a lifebelt or even a lifeboat. And importantly, a drowning person does not study the theory of lifebelts before grabbing one. A government facing crisis will need something to grab onto immediately, and something which they can understand instinctively.
Beveridge, Keynes, and the tax justice movement all provided lifebelts. So could MMT. It could provide; it does provide, a coherent explanation of what a government can do in a crisis. Its practical narrative must therefore be ready before the emergency. Political necessity can then turn an alternative idea into government policy, and that's what we need to be ready for.
We should not want this crisis. I stress that. I do not because crises cause pain, and I hate that idea. But the fact that we are going to get a crisis, I think unavoidably, does make preparation for this transition necessary.
The 2008 financial crisis caused enormous and lasting damage. Another major economic breakdown could be even worse. Think of the 1930s if you want to get your head around this, on the basis that no action, or only neoliberal action, is taken in response to the crisis that might develop soon, and then realise why an alternative is necessary.
Neoliberalism is making crisis unavoidable. The responsible response is to prepare an MMT alternative beforehand. Otherwise, the opportunity for constructive change could be lost.
What all this means is that the transition to MMT could come much sooner than people expect. People talk about it to me as if it is something that will happen in the dim and distant future. I think it is going to happen soon, in a matter of, maybe not months, but years most likely.
And the next major crisis will force politicians to reconsider their basic economic policies, and there will be fundamental change. They will need an alternative that explains how government can respond. People will demand it from them, and they will not accept austerity this time. The people of France and the people of Spain are already showing that. People's anxiety in general, expressed in their alienation from government in this country and so many others, shows that the appetite for change is real.
MMT already describes the monetary system those politicians are trying to manage. The task is now to make the practical possibilities from truly understanding that system very clear. When crisis comes, MMT must be ready to become the alternative game in town. That's my message. I intend to be ready. I am writing a book as the foundation for what I think is necessary. I hope we will have further discussions here on this point.
That's my opinion, but what's yours? There is a poll down below. Please let us have your comments. We do appreciate them. We do analyse and look at them. We do want to understand what your position is because it might differ from ours.
If you do like this video, please say so. Please do share it. Please do subscribe to the channel. Please do hit that bell so you're told when we make another video.
And if you would like to support our work, because our work is going to be needed during the course of the coming crisis, then if you'd like to buy us a coffee, that would be great.
Poll
Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:
There are links to this blog's glossary in the above post that explain technical terms used in it. Follow them for more explanations.
You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.
And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:

Buy me a coffee!

I like your hospital building analogy, which is borne out by the wonderful (sic) Nightingale Hospitals, set up during Covid to care for thousands of patients. Some £500 million was wasted on them and they treated fewer than 1,000 patients, some treated none, because they did not have any staff. Staff in the original hospitals were under huge pressure and working additional hours so could not possibly be sent to the new hospitals. I believe there was also a lack of equipment.
Money is not the answer, resources are critical.
A great example.
I think Neoliberalism has already failed and the consequent crisis is unfolding right now. So it’s a question of how bad must things get before change comes. If we want to avert even more suffering, we must understand what is keeping Neoliberalism going. Your understanding of this, Richard, is far, far deeper than mine, but I think there are three main pillars of Neoliberalism that are holding it up. One is fear of change amongst politicians, civil servants and advisers. Another is the significant army of individuals engaged in the Neoliberalism industry – investors, many institutions, bond traders etc etc – who are doing well out of it and seem to have a quasi-religious belief in it. The third is the interconnected, international nature of Neoliberalism. It’s not just the UK. Neoliberalism exists across the World and is collapsing globally.
There needs to be a strategy, in my view, that tackles each of these pillars if we are to minimise the misery that Neoliberalism is causing. Politicians and their supporting organisations need to be filled with confidence that a new approach won’t break everything. Those engaged in delivering Neoliberalism need to be offered an alternative way to make returns that they can have faith in. And these things must be done globally.
Maybe the time has come for greater cooperation and a unified approach amongst all the organisations and individuals pushing for a MMT-based economy. That will mean compromise, and that can be hard. But a fractured approach is doomed to fail. I know little or nothing about the international scene, but in the UK there are a number of players – you of course, MMTUK, GIMMS, The 99% etc. Is now the time for you all to come together and issue a clear manifesto and delivery plan?
I think your identification of the three pillars sustaining neoliberalism is useful, although I would add a fourth: the extent to which neoliberal assumptions have become embedded in what passes for economic common sense. Many politicians, civil servants, journalists and economists cannot imagine an alternative because they have never seriously considered one.
That is why changing the economic narrative matters. Unless people understand that government is not financially constrained like a household, that markets are political creations, and that the economy should meet people’s needs, we risk reproducing neoliberalism under another name.
I agree that cooperation is needed. But I would distinguish between agreeing on how money works and agreeing on what we should do with that understanding.
MMT explains monetary operations. It is not a political programme. A credible alternative must go much further, addressing public services, inequality, housing, employment, climate change, democratic accountability and economic power.
I am willing to work with others who share those objectives. But I am less convinced that negotiating a single manifesto between existing organisations is the best starting point. We could spend considerable energy agreeing organisational positions rather than developing ideas and building public understanding.
Nor must we wait for international agreement. Change can begin nationally, with successful examples encouraging others.
What we need is a coherent, comprehensible and credible alternative that people can understand, believe in and campaign for. That requires cooperation, but also a movement much wider than existing MMT organisations.
I see my role as helping provide the ideas, explanations and arguments such a movement needs. Others must help turn them into political organisation and action.
The important thing is to start building that alternative now, before neoliberalism inflicts even more damage.
I think, for what it’s worth, you are absolutely right here.
Reagan fed off Thatcher’s reforms to spread his ‘Reaganomics ‘.
Thanks. Understood. I do agree that any manifesto needs to set out a plan of action and not merely describe the mechanics of money creation. I just hope that at least one of the organisations I mentioned gets going with it. I feel that the time of opposing Neoliberalism is coming to an end, because it is collapsing. Now is the time for new leadership, new hope and a new direction.
I am….
Perhaps the fifth to which I think Richard you alluded but requires to be more explicitly articulated is that economics courses, lecturers at virtually all universities and the mainstream economic journals across the globe are orthodox neoclassical and neoliberal. Therefore, all the students graduating in Economics and PPE courses are all trained in the same cult, then move into finance and politics, thus perpetuating the cult! Max Planck stated that “new scientific ideas do not win by changing the minds of established scientists, but rather because older opponents eventually die out and are replaced by a new generation.” Unfortunately that doesn’t seem to happen in economics!
Agreed
Another one to add to the list is covid. Businesses needed supporting and NHS ramped up. Johnson & Sunak didn’t think twice and just issued the money, an extra £250bn in 20/21. It’s a shame there wasn’t a debate about it at the time and the general public shown that there really is a magic money tree. Covid always my mic drop argument.
Agreed, Kevan
The ‘Finding the Money’ film featuring Stephanie Kelton is now freely available on YouTube as well as the MMTAction website.
I gather so.
At last.
I might post it here.
Bill,
Simply by copying and pasting your words into Google I found the documentary on YouTube, it was made in 2024. I have only watched the first 6 minutes of 95 (it’s nearly bedtime here in Tasmania right now ) but that alone is dynamite! I will watch all of it very soon. Maybe we, the regular visitors to this blog, should agree to watch the whole thing and exchange comments on it on an agreed date.
A brave, hopeful post, and rightly so.
My worry is that we are at the moment offered a blizzard of false alternatives to any oncoming crisis.
‘There is no money’ – leading to the empowerment of crypto (levering in privately owned money) and austerity.
‘Chuck them back into the sea/pull up the drawbridge’ – the response to immigration and the lie that we cannot afford services because of ‘incomers’.
‘Facism’ – that we need a strong, hard leadership style to essentially stop caring about others in order to survive.
‘False wars’ – where do you start? We ignore the war on want at home, assist other dodgy wars and seem prepared to sacrifice more to defend what – ‘our way of life’?!! I find our way of life indefensible at the moment.
‘Cultural Zionism’ – never mind ‘cultural Marxism’ (I wish – well parts of it!), we are encouraged to not question Israel too much because we will be called ‘anti-Semites’ if we do. Yet, looking back at history, Israel’s conduct in that region has not helped humanity at all.
One thing we know about Neo-liberalism – thank you Philip Mirowski – is how it never lets a crisis go to waste.
The challenge and of course real risk when a crisis comes isnt that things will change it is what the change will be
With 170% of ecological overshoot we have very few resources actually available to us. We survive living this way by drawing down future resources and destroying them. It is not sustainable, and it will not be made sustainable by a “green transition”, which just requires yet more of the Earth’s limited resources to be used for a mass “renewable” build that will have to be repeated for it to be sustained.
Consumerism and the market economy in general are both incompatible with a habitable planet. We need to try a different way. Getting rid of money would probably be a good start. The only function of money is to allow some to have more than others, after all.
Please be realistic. Suggesting getting rid of money is not.
We do need a viable proposal for when the time comes.
That proposal can’t simply be to account of MMT when choosing policies. That’s too big a bite even with your cleverly drafted clear explanations. So I have a quick and simple proposal that, I think, both makes sense from an MMT perspective and would hopefully lead a greater understanding and use of MMT to guide policy.
The Chancellor should announce, under provisions of the 1998 Bank of England Act, that he is suspending interest payments on reserves held by commercial banks at the Bank of England. He can explain,with a sorrowful face, that we must all, including the banks, take a share of the burden in these difficult times. And since, he would say, he understands the banks position, he will offer them the option to buy new low yield government bonds (say 1%), but that they are, of course, at liberty to invest their reserves in other higher yielding assets. That last, of course, is nonsense, pure PR puff, because the banks, in aggregate, can’t reduce their holdings of reserves other than by buying new gilts.
This is aimed at forcing the banks and bond markets to realise that the government is in control, if it chooses. The immediate affect would be to save about £20 billon per annum. The secondary effect is to force the banks to buy low yield gilts. And, because the government is now “borrowing” at low rates “from the banks”, it no longer needs to sell high yield gilts. Pretty soon yields on gilts generally would reduce significantly, proving that “Bond Vigilantes” we’re not in control.
This, IMO, would be a simple, quick, first step to transition to properly taking account of MMT.
Noted.
I am working on this.
Politicians already know about MMT. It’s just that they only use it to enrich the already rich – their mates on PPI fast lanes or massive software projects that aren’t delivered, or who run bailed out banks, or lobby for data centres, or run privatised services. For these people, there really is a magic money tree, and they ain’t going to let anyone else eat of it.
Ditto the tech bros – they know how money really works too. That’s they keep needing their stock values to grow exponentially, so they can treat their stocks like currency, including using it to pay people.
So the question isn’t ‘when will they turn to MMT?’, but ‘when will they turn to MMT for the common good?’
Agreed
In 1945 most people had either not heard of Keynes or didn’t understand what he was saying. . They HAD seen the 1930s answer in a form of austerity hadn’t worked and were prepared to try something different. But enough people who were in positions of power or prepared to stand for election, probably did so. The public or much of it, had lost faith in the ability of the Conservatives to deliver change. That is similar to today. I feel many have also lost faith in the experts who crop up on TV to say why ‘there is no alternative.’ So we might be moving into a paradigm shift. They can come quite quickly when they get going.
Agreed
While MMT is indeed based on a correct explanation/understanding of modern monetary economies it remains a very long way from being adopted by any current political party. Indeed all parties are doing their upmost to deny its core ideas, with media (social and mainstream encouragement).
There is a simple reason. MMT is probably understood by <5% of the population and even those people have incomplete understanding of its implications. I would guesstimate that only 2-3% of voters both understand nd would vote for policies based on MMT today.
My evidence is only anecdotal but I am typically in a minority of one among business colleagues (typically C suite level peers), social groups and sports players when it comes to supporting the core ideas of MMT. Most think I am deranged! It’s now rather like Brexit, a topic that is too confrontational to bring up.
I am an ex-banker and all my banking friends still and without exception believe in loanable funds theory etc and dismiss the BoE and other articles point out why this is wrong.
So I have zero confidence that MMT will be part of any political agenda in the UK in the foreseeable future. That fills me with no joy to write.
Why have you ignored what I actually said, rather than engaging with the suggestions I made?
I am well aware that MMT is not widely understood. That is precisely why I spend so much time explaining how money works, why tax does not fund government spending, and why the constraints on government action are real resources and inflation rather than the availability of money.
But your claim that no political party is taking MMT seriously is also incorrect. Last weekend, the Green Party adopted an MMT approach to the macroeconomic management of the UK economy, should it form a government. I recognise that the prospect of the Greens forming a government is remote at present, but that does not diminish the significance of this decision. It demonstrates that these ideas are beginning to influence political thinking.
More importantly, I was not suggesting that we should wait until everyone understands MMT before change can happen, or that every political party must formally adopt it.
My argument was about developing a coherent alternative to neoliberalism, explaining it in language people can understand, and building confidence that change is possible.
People do not need to understand monetary theory to recognise the need for functioning public services, affordable housing, secure employment, climate action and greater equality.
They need a credible explanation of how these things can be delivered, and why the claim that we cannot afford them is so often wrong.
That is what I am trying to provide.
Your pessimism may reflect your experience, but it does not address my suggestions. Indeed, if misunderstanding is as widespread as you suggest, that makes developing and communicating an alternative more urgent.
I would welcome your thoughts on what I actually proposed.
Ok, that was not the reply I was expecting!
You posed a question – when will MMT actually be put into practice – and I gave my answer and my reasons.
Many people recognise the needs you describe but still fall for the arguments that “there is no money”, or accept that standard media questions, “where will the money come from?”.
FWIW, I voted Green at the last election in full knowledge that they are closer to power than MMT is to be included in any school textbook or policy recommendation.
If anything interestsin MMT may have peaked. Kelton did her very best with both her book and films and some momentum seems to be building. Keen and yourself are still fighting the battle, true. Other MMT advocates seem happier to be arguing among themselves.
In the meantime the core macro agendas remain unchanged. We might not like this, but that’s hard to deny. The next UK budget will illustrate this all to clearly and sadly.
And you still have not engaged with a word I said. Why?
Come on Clara!
Go for it! What might you do to change the perception off MMT in the public’s view? The Neo-liberals will have a host of ‘alternatives’ posing as helpful solutions if/when a crisis hits. So, MMT needs ideas and it is out there.
Think about it, come back and tell us. The biggest puzzle is that you seem to think its all over before its even started. Is that the case? Get your thinking cap on if it isn’t.
Pilgrim. MMT isn’t short of ideas. It’s short of adherents. The only party that has taken it on, is an electoral irrelevance, despite my vote.
perhaps what it is short of is an acceptable face? Kenton provided that for a while. Otherwise what and I other women like me see is a group of angry men of a certain age (Saunders, Keen, Mosley, Murphy). Do they resonate with women like me or the next generation of voters more importantly?
Give us an acceptable, friendly, positive face and we may get somewhere …
I can’t help being male
And why not be angry?
Why aren’t you angry?
Clara,
How about Matt Crocker from Deakin University near Melbourne? The film set is a bit Playshool but I like the format.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vqsMGUH8Phk
Clare, anger moves me to action and has done, whatever age I was. It is part of how we are fully human. Of course it depends on what you DO with your anger – blow someone’s brains out, or make a nuisance of yourself till a community centre gets built, help start a foodbank, found a community charity, or do informal advocacy for victims of the powerful,or to political campaigning. Those are some of the places where my anger has taken me, and they all involved me working, for the last 35 years, alongside others (mostly women), of various ages, also motivated by constructive anger, to come up with imperfect, but better than nothing solutions to lessen human misery that was within our power to lessen. Your comment about “angry men of a certain age” is, shall I politely say, “regrettable”?
My holy book says, “in your anger do not sin”, which seems wise, and it also warns against destructive or vengeful anger. It records one incident where anger motivated Jesus to heal a man on the Sabbath (he was about 30 at the time).
He also threw over some tables in the Temple. That was well placed anger.
Why am I not angry?
Because anger alienates rather than unifies.
Because anger inhibits debate rather than encouraging it
Because anger leaves you shouting from the sidelines rather than leading from the centre.
When you consider the self proclaimed advocates of MMT, how many are alienated, suppress debate and are left shouting from the sidelines while the rest are left debating on false principles?
I disagree with almost every assumption you make here.
Anger does not necessarily alienate. It can unite people who recognise that they are suffering from the same injustices. Much of the progress towards greater social justice has been driven by people who were angry enough about their circumstances to demand change.
Nor does anger necessarily inhibit debate. It can provoke precisely the debate that those benefiting from the status quo would rather avoid. The alternative is too often a polite discussion in which nothing fundamental is ever challenged.
And why should anyone assume that leadership must come from the centre? If the centre is committed to economic assumptions that are demonstrably wrong, remaining there simply perpetuates the problem.
I am angry about poverty, inequality, failing public services, unnecessary austerity and the deliberate refusal to consider alternatives. I make no apology for that.
But anger does not prevent me from researching, explaining, writing, debating or proposing solutions. It provides much of the motivation for doing so.
You also appear to confuse anger with an inability to engage constructively. They are not the same thing.
The question I would ask is why you are more concerned about the anger of those challenging a failing economic system than about the consequences of the system itself.
Surely those consequences are what deserve our attention?
RobertJ- the SME book reminds us not to bare false witness too. Sousing Chat GPT data lets consider some of the leading names in MMT, many of whom come across as pretty angry…
Sanders – 85, white male
Mosler – 77, white male
Mitchell – 74, white male
Randall Wray- 73, white male
(Keen – 73, white male)
(Murphy – 68, white male)
Then we get to less angry, younger, and talented writers in Europe such as
Ehnts – 49, white male
but not forgetting
Kelton – 57 white female
(Tcherneva – unknown age, white female)
So, hard to falsify the hypothesis that MMT is dominated by angry men of a certain age, even if that lands badly with you (sorry for that).
But let the anger from that subside and think hard – as Pilgrim might say – about whether MMT might just have an image problem.
Who in that list, am I likely to naturally relate to (hint not someone who is rude on the internet)? More importantly, who is ringing bells with the next generation of voters?
Kelton provided an acceptable face for many – she was invited by global banks to present at conference etc. she was articulate, polite, rarely angry, amusing and easy to relate too. There is a message there or at least should be, if MMT is going to have a chance of entering mainstream debate.
Politely, no one is stopping you from joining in, except you.
Why not be angry enough to do so and stop shouting from the sidelines? Be the change you want
Clare – my post above, in response to yours, is solely concerned with my own actions and motivations, in response to human misery caused by injstice.
It says nothing about your claims or opinions,other than to offer a different point of view, based on my verifiable personal experience. So I am genuinely confused by your reference to “false witness”. Who exactly, do you suggest is “bearing false witness” and when, where, and with what words?
I would welcome your clarification, for the public record, that you are not suggesting that I was bearing false witness, (ie: lying), in the post I made at
https://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2026/10/09/when-will-politicians-turn-to-mmt/#comment-1096018
as I would regard any such suggestion, published in a public forum, as very unfortunate, and harmful to my reputation. My post is truthful and its factual claims can be verified, but that would be a tedious unproductive waste of time. Perhaps I have misunderstood, and no such suggesion of lying was intended?
I’m off to bed.
An MMT-believing Gov’t will need to
DECIDE (what they WANT to do, to benefit we, the people)
BELIEVE (that you an do it).
PARTNER (with collaborators who share at least some of your goals)
PREPARE (for the attacks, the propaganda, and “events, dear boy” when the plans encounter unpredictable reality)
PLAN the project (knowing that the MONEY at least, IS available, plan in detail, how, with what, with whom, when, and what if…?)
PROCLAIM (realistic, robust, above all HONEST communication with the public, who are not used to honest politicians)
PROCEED PROACTIVELY (get on with DELIVERING change, instead of promising it, or doing reactive PR-dominated crisis management)
PERSIST (courageously, & robustly, because the opposition will be very noisy)
Agreed
Good to hear you’re writing a new book. I hope it will serve as a blueprint and inspiration (as Keynes’ General Theory and Gslbraith’s Affluent Society previously did) for governments to turn to when neoliberalism inevitably fails. Can I tentatively suggest that, to meet the comments above about international cooperation and to ensure maximum (favoursble) coverage in the MSM, it might be helpful if the book was presented as a collective work with a global perspective by asking MMT supporting economists like Stephanie Kelton or James Galbraith in the US, Dirk Ehnts or Peter Bofinger in Germany, Steve Keen down under, Eduardo Espinosa in Spain, Ivan Invernizzi in Italy, Marc Levoie in France and Yanis Varoufakis to contribute a chapter each on their countries and the EU?
It is deliberately short and lays the groundwork for more to follow. When I sign the contract – probably on Monday- the publisher has the option on the next one. I think it will need at least two, maybe three.
In terms of the sustainability and scarcity of resources has Richard spoke to Kate Raworth known for her Doughnut Economics?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doughnut_(economic_model)
Yes
But it has few macro answers, IMO
The key to MMT adoption/realisation will ultimately be in the messaging.
The Thatcher coterie succeeded not because Keynesian policies failed or were ineffective but because they never iterated to deal with the circumstances of the time. Thatcher cynically, destructively and disingenuously attacked Keynesianism to suit her own ends.
If Thatcher had the interest of the British public at heart she could have taken the Keynesianism of the time, iterated it with Tory messaging and built on the benefits it was bringing. Much like the social housing project under Macmillan, but no…. Thatcher had a whole different agenda.
So in short, yes we must be ready, things are coming to a head in France, Spain, Germany, the US, Latin America, Belgium, Bolivia, Asia and Africa and not least here in the UK with disaffection spilling onto the streets.
The time is coming.
It is….
The fact is even once we’ve implemented MMT we’ll always have to be on our guard as to how it could be subverted since human nature doesn’t change and the wealthy and their acolytes will be back at some point.
The Polish economist Michal Kalecki predicted in the 1950s that the bosses were unlikely to tolerate Full Employment for long.
https://econjared.substack.com/p/michael-kalecki-full-employment-political
This is an excellent history of how mass unemployment was reintroduced:
https://thetruthaboutunemployment.wordpress.com
The reason so many politicians reject ideas such as MMT is that it gives them the excuse ‘there is no money left’ to abdicate their responsibilities while being in the pocket of ( and often in the pay of) those that profit from the current destructive system.
[…] said in a video yesterday that politicians would reach for MMT when they were desperate, and they have no choice but to […]
[…] said in a video yesterday that politicians would reach for modern monetary theory, which argues that governments issuing […]
I have to say there seems to be an assumption among posters that MMT will be adopted at some point by a left-leaning government to enable a politics of care. But of course MMT in and of itself is politically neutral. For it to take root and permanently displace the ‘household budget’ view of the economy, it would need, in a democracy, to be accepted across the political spectrum.
Are we prepared for the reality of MMT being embraced by a right-wing government? They would no doubt use those exact same financial freedoms to achieve structural aims quite different to the politics of care. It raises an interesting question: if we successfully remove the fiscal shackles from the state, how do we ensure the tool doesn’t eventually weaponise the very things we are fighting against?
I am working on themes around this right now.