The EU VAT gap estimate for the UK is £1 billion more than the UK admits to

Posted on

The EU published new VAT gap data last week for all 28 member states.

The UK summary is here (click the image for a bigger version):

Screen Shot 2014-10-27 at 09.28.57

 

The EU think that in 2012 the UK VAT gap was 10.4% of total potential VAT payable. At 2012 exchange rates the value was £13,428 million (£13.4 billion). The EU says this is very close to the UK estimate.

There's just one problem with that claim: the latest UK estimate of the VAT gap is for 2012-13 (so near enough the same period) and is for a gap of 10.9% at a cost of £12.4 billion. I don't think £13.4 billion is close to £12.4 billion: it is £1 billion.

One of these estimates is better than the other. I know which I am inclined to believe because it was not prepared by the tax authority publishing it, and that's precisely why I say HMRC should not be responsible for monitoring the tax gap.

Note: Updated at 14.30 on 27 October because an incorrect exchange rate was used in the first version