You’re already paying the price for AI – and it’s costing you a lot

Posted on

Artificial intelligence promises economic growth and greater productivity. But what if AI is already making life more expensive for everyone?

In this video, I examine the hidden costs of AI, from rising electricity bills and computer prices to increased demand for water, infrastructure and skilled workers, whilst leaving many other jobs under threat.

I also explain how AI investment may be pushing up interest rates, increasing borrowing costs and threatening jobs and wages.

While technology companies and investors anticipate enormous profits, ordinary people could be left paying the price through higher living costs, economic insecurity and reduced public investment.

AI risks privatising profits while passing its costs on to society.

Governments must assess these costs and ensure that technological development benefits everyone, not just wealthy investors.

We are already paying for AI. Is it really worth the price?

This is the first of two videos examining the economic costs and financial risks of artificial intelligence.

This is the audio version:

This is the transcript:


The whole of the financial world is euphoric today about the success of the Anthropic flotation on the stock market in the USA. Tens of billions of dollars have poured into the company. Everyone thinks they're going to make money. But I want to ask a different question in this video, and it is: are we already paying the price for AI?

AI is supposed to transform our economy and deliver extraordinary growth. We are promised higher productivity, better jobs, and new opportunities. But none of those benefits is guaranteed, and we're also being warned of the risks from AI.

Meanwhile, AI is already imposing substantial costs on society. Most people have very little idea of the true scale of those costs or where the risks are arising. So this is the first of two videos that I'm creating, examining what AI is really costing us.

The cost of AI is already being passed on to everyone. That is the message in this video. AI requires enormous investment in equipment, energy, and infrastructure. It also competes for skilled workers and scarce natural resources. And politicians say these deliver growth, the only thing they ever worry about. But the reality is that these demands affect prices throughout the economy. And people who will never use AI are still going to find themselves paying for it. The question is: can the benefits of AI ever justify these costs, which are going to be borne by everyone in society?

And, let's be clear: AI is creating inflationary pressure. AI companies require enormous quantities of computer chips and memory. They are competing with manufacturers of ordinary electronic equipment. When demand exceeds supply, and that is what is happening, prices tend to rise. Computers, phones, cameras, gaming consoles, cars and more are all becoming more expensive as a consequence of the demand from AI companies for chips, and we are paying that price because we are having to pay more for the other things that we want in life, even if we don't want the AI that's embedded within them.

And AI is also creating increased demand for electricity. AI generation does require vast amounts of electrical power. There's no question about that. We know that's a fact. We are seeing that in all the projections for the growth in demand for fossil fuels, which are now coming out. And the proposed expansion of AI will increase that demand considerably. Ignore the impact on the planet for the moment. If electricity supplies cannot keep pace with the demand from AI, prices will rise. And that will have an effect on households and businesses across the economy already struggling with a cost-of-living crisis driven by energy costs. People who will never use AI can still face higher electricity bills as a consequence of it. That's my point.

And on top of that, AI is putting pressure on water supplies and our climate. Data centres consume considerable quantities of water for cooling. They can compete with households, agriculture, and industry for water as a result, and we know that water supplies are already scarce.

And some data centres are even considering building their own gas-fired power stations at present because they can't get the electricity they want, in part to generate power and in part to cool their systems.

This could also increase gas demand, pushing up energy prices once again, and at the same time, increasing carbon emissions. AI could therefore make environmental sustainability much harder to achieve in this country and around the world, and at the same time, it could increase prices. This is its threat.

And we know at the same time it's increasing the price of something else, and that something else is money. AI investment is already affecting interest rates. Investors are not only buying shares in these companies. They're lending money to them as well. And the enormous amounts of money that they are borrowing is pushing up interest rates around the globe.

The demand to buy shares in these companies is so high, and the demand for money to lend to these companies is so large that people are selling other financial assets to achieve these outcomes. People like pension funds, life assurance funds, and those who manage your money on your behalf are selling things like government bonds and are buying AI investments instead, but that has real consequences.

If a government bond is sold, the real interest rate on that bond effectively goes up. Bond prices and the interest rate that is effectively paid on them run inversely to each other. And AI speculation may therefore be contributing to higher borrowing costs that we're seeing around the world right now, and that is important.

Higher bond yields, which is what we are seeing, have consequences for everyone. Bond yields do not only influence the cost of government borrowing. They have an impact right across the economy. Mortgages, business loans and other forms of credit can become more expensive. Rents tend to rise as a result. And higher yields can also increase the apparent cost of government borrowing, and politicians take that opportunity to claim that they cannot afford to spend so much on essential programmes like healthcare, education, social security, and more.

Private speculation on AI may then be creating pressures for which governments are blamed, and we're all paying the price for that, most especially if you're in the lower half of the income strata and are therefore a net beneficiary of government spending, which is broadly how the world is divided.

At the same time, AI is competing for resources that society needs elsewhere. Data centres require skilled workers, engineers, and construction materials. Those resources cannot then be used for other purposes. Housing, transport projects and flood defences may face higher costs or delays as a result. And economists call this an opportunity cost because alternatives are sacrificed.

But is it worth sacrificing all these things that we know we need on the altar of AI? Why is it that AI is the best use of society's limited resources? Would those resources be better off used to build houses rather than build a little bit of extra data or the ability to generate another silly photograph?

AI is also threatening employment and wages. Now, I know that some people will be getting jobs building all these new investments in AI. But in the long term, are we going to see more jobs? Nobody really thinks that we are. There are undoubtedly jobs that are already being replaced by or changed by AI. Even highly skilled technical workers are finding that their employment is threatened. Workers who retain their jobs could face downward pressure on wages as well. And greater insecurity can reduce spending power right across the economy, with knock-on effects all over the place, including the whole of the retail and hospitality sectors. AI is then a threat.

The benefits of AI may also increasingly flow to technology owners rather than workers, and that matters. Can society afford this? Can we afford a world where work does not pay, AI does, and the AI owners are ever richer whilst the rest of the world is ever poorer?

So, what are we actually getting in return for all this cost? That's the question to ask, because if we can't answer it, there is no justification for what we are paying for AI, whether directly or not.

Now, I accept that AI does have potentially valuable applications in medicine and scientific research, and there are some other areas where it is possible that some substantial benefits may arise. But the benefits experienced by most people so far have been decidedly modest. Better web searches, a few generated images which people might laugh at, and photo manipulation all have their uses, but they're not that important.

So, do these benefits justify the enormous resources being consumed by AI? And if not, is it time to call a halt on this investment? Because what I can see is that AI is socialising costs while privatising potential benefits, and that's a problem.

The companies developing AI hope to generate enormous profits. Their shareholders expect to benefit from the technology. Meanwhile, the wider public, including you and me, everybody else who's watching this video, because we are not alone, will be paying the price of AI. We're paying it in the form of higher costs. We're paying it in the form of greater insecurity. And people who have no influence over AI investment are bearing the consequences of it.

This familiar pattern in capitalism raises essential questions about economic power and fairness. And in that case, our governments, wherever you are in the world, need to assess the full costs of AI. The economic benefits of AI must be compared with its wider costs. These include energy demand, water consumption, and environmental damage. Employment risk, increasing inequality, and displaced public investment are, all of which must be considered when looking at the scorecard for AI.

AI companies should be required to bear the costs that they impose on society. Technological development must serve the public interest, and at the moment there is absolutely no indication that that will be the case when it comes to AI.

And let's be clear: we are told that AI is inevitable, and we're being told that AI must be accommodated because it will deliver growth, but I am questioning this. I am implying that these assumptions may even be wrong because, just considering alone the externalities of this technology that I've discussed in this video, we can see the problems, and I will go into much greater depth on some other costs in the second video in this series.

The scale and direction of the investment are economic and political choices, and governments can and should decide how resources should be allocated within their economies, and it looks to me as though they are abandoning that responsibility at present. They should also be determining who should bear the costs of technological change.

The interests of society must matter more than the ambitions of AI investors. They might be euphoric about the consequences of the Anthropic flotation, but growth is no justification in itself, most especially on a finite planet where any growth always has costs.

And the real question is then: will AI improve people's lives? Progress cannot be measured by investment alone or corporate market valuations. It must be measured by improvements in human well-being, and AI that will just make life more expensive, insecure, and unequal, most especially for those who do not use it, is not a success by that measure.

In the next video, I'll examine the financial risks and economic power behind AI, but at this moment, just note my point: we are already paying for AI. It's time to ask whether it's worth the price. I'm not entirely sure.

That's what I think. What do you think? There is, of course, room for comments down below.


The whole of the financial world is euphoric today about the success of the Anthropic flotation on the stock market in the USA. Tens of billions of dollars have poured into the company. Everyone thinks they're going to make money. But I want to ask a different question in this video, and it is: are we already paying the price for AI?

AI is supposed to transform our economy and deliver extraordinary growth. We are promised higher productivity, better jobs, and new opportunities. But none of those benefits is guaranteed, and we're also being warned of the risks from AI.

Meanwhile, AI is already imposing substantial costs on society. Most people have very little idea of the true scale of those costs or where the risks are arising. So this is the first of two videos that I'm creating, examining what AI is really costing us.

The cost of AI is already being passed on to everyone. That is the message in this video. AI requires enormous investment in equipment, energy, and infrastructure. It also competes for skilled workers and scarce natural resources. And politicians say these deliver growth, the only thing they ever worry about. But the reality is that these demands affect prices throughout the economy. And people who will never use AI are still going to find themselves paying for it. The question is: can the benefits of AI ever justify these costs, which are going to be borne by everyone in society?

And, let's be clear: AI is creating inflationary pressure. AI companies require enormous quantities of computer chips and memory. They are competing with manufacturers of ordinary electronic equipment. When demand exceeds supply, and that is what is happening, prices tend to rise. Computers, phones, cameras, gaming consoles, cars and more are all becoming more expensive as a consequence of the demand from AI companies for chips, and we are paying that price because we are having to pay more for the other things that we want in life, even if we don't want the AI that's embedded within them.

And AI is also creating increased demand for electricity. AI generation does require vast amounts of electrical power. There's no question about that. We know that's a fact. We are seeing that in all the projections for the growth in demand for fossil fuels, which are now coming out. And the proposed expansion of AI will increase that demand considerably. Ignore the impact on the planet for the moment. If electricity supplies cannot keep pace with the demand from AI, prices will rise. And that will have an effect on households and businesses across the economy already struggling with a cost-of-living crisis driven by energy costs. People who will never use AI can still face higher electricity bills as a consequence of it. That's my point.

And on top of that, AI is putting pressure on water supplies and our climate. Data centres consume considerable quantities of water for cooling. They can compete with households, agriculture, and industry for water as a result, and we know that water supplies are already scarce.

And some data centres are even considering building their own gas-fired power stations at present because they can't get the electricity they want, in part to generate power and in part to cool their systems.

This could also increase gas demand, pushing up energy prices once again, and at the same time, increasing carbon emissions. AI could therefore make environmental sustainability much harder to achieve in this country and around the world, and at the same time, it could increase prices. This is its threat.

And we know at the same time it's increasing the price of something else, and that something else is money. AI investment is already affecting interest rates. Investors are not only buying shares in these companies. They're lending money to them as well. And the enormous amounts of money that they are borrowing is pushing up interest rates around the globe.

The demand to buy shares in these companies is so high, and the demand for money to lend to these companies is so large that people are selling other financial assets to achieve these outcomes. People like pension funds, life assurance funds, and those who manage your money on your behalf are selling things like government bonds and are buying AI investments instead, but that has real consequences.

If a government bond is sold, the real interest rate on that bond effectively goes up. Bond prices and the interest rate that is effectively paid on them run inversely to each other. And AI speculation may therefore be contributing to higher borrowing costs that we're seeing around the world right now, and that is important.

Higher bond yields, which is what we are seeing, have consequences for everyone. Bond yields do not only influence the cost of government borrowing. They have an impact right across the economy. Mortgages, business loans and other forms of credit can become more expensive. Rents tend to rise as a result. And higher yields can also increase the apparent cost of government borrowing, and politicians take that opportunity to claim that they cannot afford to spend so much on essential programmes like healthcare, education, social security, and more.

Private speculation on AI may then be creating pressures for which governments are blamed, and we're all paying the price for that, most especially if you're in the lower half of the income strata and are therefore a net beneficiary of government spending, which is broadly how the world is divided.

At the same time, AI is competing for resources that society needs elsewhere. Data centres require skilled workers, engineers, and construction materials. Those resources cannot then be used for other purposes. Housing, transport projects and flood defences may face higher costs or delays as a result. And economists call this an opportunity cost because alternatives are sacrificed.

But is it worth sacrificing all these things that we know we need on the altar of AI? Why is it that AI is the best use of society's limited resources? Would those resources be better off used to build houses rather than build a little bit of extra data or the ability to generate another silly photograph?

AI is also threatening employment and wages. Now, I know that some people will be getting jobs building all these new investments in AI. But in the long term, are we going to see more jobs? Nobody really thinks that we are. There are undoubtedly jobs that are already being replaced by or changed by AI. Even highly skilled technical workers are finding their employments are threatened. Workers who retain their jobs could face downward pressure on wages as well. And greater insecurity can reduce spending power right across the economy, with knock-on effects all over the place, including the whole of the retail and hospitality sectors. AI is then a threat.

The benefits of AI may also increasingly flow to technology owners rather than workers, and that matters. Can society afford this? Can we afford a world where work does not pay, AI does, and the AI owners are ever richer whilst the rest of the world is ever poorer?

So, what are we actually getting in return for all this cost? That's the question to ask, because if we can't answer it, there is no justification for what we are paying for AI, whether directly or not.

Now, I accept that AI does have potentially valuable applications in medicine and scientific research, and there are some other areas where it is possible that some substantial benefits may arise. But the benefits experienced by most people so far have been decidedly modest. Better web searches, a few generated images which people might laugh at, and photo manipulation all have their uses, but they're not that important.

So, do these benefits justify the enormous resources being consumed by AI? And if not, is it time to call a halt on this investment? Because what I can see is that AI is socialising costs while privatising potential benefits, and that's a problem.

The companies developing AI hope to generate enormous profits. Their shareholders expect to benefit from the technology. Meanwhile, the wider public, including you and me, everybody else who's watching this video, because we are not alone, will be paying the price of AI. We're paying it in the form of higher costs. We're paying it in the form of greater insecurity. And people who have no influence over AI investment are bearing the consequences of it.

This familiar pattern in capitalism raises essential questions about economic power and fairness. And in that case, our governments, wherever you are in the world, need to assess the full costs of AI. The economic benefits of AI must be compared with its wider costs. These include energy demand, water consumption, and environmental damage. Employment risk, increasing inequality, and displaced public investment, all of which must be considered when looking at the scorecard for AI.

AI companies should be required to bear the costs that they impose on society. Technological development must serve the public interest, and at the moment there is absolutely no indication that that will be the case when it comes to AI.

And let's be clear: we are told that AI is inevitable, and we're being told that AI must be accommodated because it will deliver growth, but I am questioning this. I am implying that these assumptions may even be wrong because, just considering alone the externalities of this technology that I've discussed in this video, we can see the problems, and I will go into much greater depth on some other costs in the second video in this series.

The scale and direction of the investment are economic and political choices, and governments can and should decide how resources should be allocated within their economies, and it looks to me as though they are abandoning that responsibility at present. They should also be determining who should bear the costs of technological change.

The interests of society must matter more than the ambitions of AI investors. They might be euphoric about the consequences of the Anthropic flotation, but growth is no justification in itself, most especially on a finite planet where any growth always has costs.

And the real question is then: will AI improve people's lives? Progress cannot be measured by investment alone or corporate market valuations. It must be measured by improvements in human well-being, and AI that will just make life more expensive, insecure, and unequal, most especially for those who do not use it, is not a success by that measure.

In the next video, I'll examine the financial risks and economic power behind AI, but at this moment, just note my point: we are already paying for AI. It's time to ask whether it's worth the price. I'm not entirely sure.

That's what I think. What do you think? There is, of course, room for comments down below. There's a poll as well.


Poll

What concerns you most about the growing economic costs of AI?

View Results

Loading ...

PDF of article


Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:

There are links to this blog's glossary in the above post that explain technical terms used in it. Follow them for more explanations.

You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.

And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:

  • Richard Murphy

  • Downloads Centre

    eBooks

    Debate Ammunition

    View on...

    Infographics

  • Why not search for what you are looking for...

  • Support This Site

    If you like what I do please support me on Ko-fi using credit or debit card or PayPal

  • Archives

  • Categories

  • Taxing wealth report 2024

  • Newsletter signup

    Get a daily email of my blog posts.

    Please wait...

    Thank you for sign up!

  • Podcast

  • Follow me

    LinkedIn

    LinkedIn

    Mastodon

    @RichardJMurphy

    BlueSky

    @richardjmurphy.bsky.social