Alan Milburn published his much-trailed report on managing the supposed problem of young people not in education, employment or training in the UK yesterday, and it was as intensely neoliberal as I expected.
At its core, there is a plan to remove or restructure a significant part of the social security support currently provided to young people to manage the problems that they face, including support for the most basic costs of living and to meet the additional costs that their disabilities impose. Many young people could lose support as a consequence.
Milburn then proposes providing substantial subsidies to employers, with, it would seem, remarkably few conditions attached beyond the eligibility of the young people recruited. That includes conditions relating to the number of genuinely new employment opportunities to be created, their value to young people, or their long-term consequences in providing opportunities after six-month government-funded work programmes have been completed. The asymmetry in the recommendations made is, then, staggering.
In essence, Milburn acknowledges that the private sector has failed to create employment opportunities for young people. However, he now believes, as a consequence of the standard approach to problem-solving adopted by neoliberal politicians almost everywhere, that they will do so if only some relatively minor changes are made to the incentives provided to them to recruit young people who have been out of work for extended periods.
Saying that, he does, however, fail to adequately address two things. One is that AI is currently threatening many of the jobs he wants young people to be offered. Although he acknowledges this problem, his proposed response does not appear sufficient to address it. The second is that there will, almost invariably, be many more young people available to employers who do not have any of the disadvantages of those previously unemployed. No convincing explanation as to how either difficulty is to be overcome appears in the report, as far as I can see.
As a result, and to be blunt, I do not think that Milburn's scheme is going to work. That is not least because, although employers can receive subsidies for recruiting young people who have been out of education, employment or training for six months, no young person will qualify for the proposed guaranteed six-month job until they have been in that situation for at least 12 months without success. Milburn proposes other forms of support before then, but these do not amount to a guarantee of employment. This remaining 12-month delay, no doubt retained to save costs, means this scheme cannot achieve its goals.
Twelve months is an extraordinarily long time in the life of a young person to be seeking employment without success. During that period, they might well have completed hundreds of job applications, leaving them totally alienated from work, and both deskilled and demotivated in ways that will make recovery very much harder.
But there is another deeply problematic assumption inside this whole plan, and that is that the jobs to be made available will depend overwhelmingly on the private sector. Milburn does propose some public sector employment measures, but these do not appear to be the central focus of his plan.
We know that the private sector is not creating these opportunities now and, despite all the screaming and shouting their spokespeople like to do, that is not because of regulation, increased National Insurance costs or the minimum wage. Instead, it is because demand within the UK economy is being deliberately suppressed by the actions of the Bank of England at present, which it is doing by keeping interest rates artificially high. This simultaneously maintains unnecessarily high levels of unemployment.
Milburn is, then, either failing to understand the causes of unemployment in the UK or is deliberately ignoring them. Either way, his proposals are fundamentally flawed. You cannot solve an unemployment problem without first acknowledging why it exists, and you cannot create effective employment policies whilst ignoring the economic conditions that have caused the problem in the first place. He is doing both. That is why his plan will fail.
Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:
There are links to this blog's glossary in the above post that explain technical terms used in it. Follow them for more explanations.
You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.
And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:

Buy me a coffee!

Totally agreed.
This is cruel populist nonsense from Milburn (except that the populism may be confined to Westminster as a lot of us parents out here know how tough it is for the young at the moment).
On C4 News last night, he spoke about the public sector and so many people approaching retirement and how it needed to step up and do their bit. So, when saying this has he considered the cuts to local government and is Labour going to put the cuts back? Or is he just offering cheap alternative labour?
Does he not also realise that people are postponing retirement because they cannot afford to live comfortably in the economy Burnham and his party preside over?
As you suggest Richard, its all rhubarb because cutting the social security bill is really the only objective here. nothing else.
How stupid does the STP think we are?
Removal of job-seeking benefits like Universal Credit, particularly Limited Capacity for Work Related Activity is problematic but not entirely against the stated goal.
Removing PIP, including the mobility element, would remove the support that disabled young adults NEED to be able to live and to be able to work. Far from encouraging work, it would remove the ability to pay the extra travel costs required that make it a possibility.
It proposes an increased amount for those living independently, so the basis is clear. Parents are expected to support disabled children until they are 25 not 18. If they can’t afford do to so, then tough. If they’re in a larger household then it pushes more into poverty when the MAJORITY of children in large households are already in poverty.
The alternative? Evict a disabled child so they qualify for that support… likely leaving destitution and harm to the young adult, making it even harder for them to work while that’s sorted out, and costing MORE to the government from providing separate housing, etc.
Reforming how young adults are supported into work is one thing, and incentives like lower NI could help, although just telling the BoE to stop creating conditions that stop the job creation would be more effective AND cheaper. But removing ESSENTIAL support from disabled people who have already been targeted by Labour welfare cuts under Starmer is just cruelty dressed up as policy.
Much to agree with.
The discussion on BBC was very much channeled around ‘business’s’ cry for reducing the minimum wage and employers NI, so they can ’employ’ more NEETS.<p>
Essentially as Richards says, this leaves out the whole context of how the economy is working. Real earnings from work have large stagnated for years -. Up to half Tesco’s workers are so underpaid that they need Universal Credit to top up – essentially a subsidy to Tesco’s £3bn annual profit.<p>
And Milburn seems intent on pushing wages down even more – at a time when BoE is pushing for ever less demand for labour. Its a doom loop – earnings needing to be lower and lower.<p>
It would be right to look at what needs doing – much of it in the Health Service, and public infrastructure – and indeed mobilise the apprentice and college system to help – but as Richard always says – Milburn is looking through the wrong end of the telescope – starting from the ‘money’ perspective rather from the real economy and society.
Leaving school is for most youngsters and parents the first time they need to make any life changing decisions. As far as I am aware there is virtually no support or preparation available at that time. That is surely the place to start not twelve months later.
I very much agree
The transition from the structure of education to the real world is a massive shock whenever it happens.
When I left school in the mid 70’s we had several chats with the careers advisor (the deputy head who had no training in the subject) and, as I was headed for ‘A’ Levels in French and Spanish she recommended bi-lingual secretarial school.
Things improved remarkably from then. Wasn’t there a national organisation called ‘Connections’ or something that was ended when the coalition government got in? W need something like that again.