I noted over this summer that we appeared to be having a traffic downturn on this blog and elsewhere. I discussed this with other people I know who publish online, and also with some people in the mainstream media, and was told that the trend was universal. An increasing alienation between the media and what people wanted to read, or even be aware of, appeared to exist.
Amongst the many publications to which I subscribe is one on Substack which deals with issues around what is happening in the press. Its author, Jez Walters, has now noted data on this trend, admittedly from the USA. As they had to say:
U.S. web traffic to 100 of the top news sites fell to 48m visits in July, down from 70m in 2024. Direct traffic, one of publishers' largest funnels, has sunk 25%. User behaviour is changing, with a huge drop-off in scrolling on publisher websites - 40% of desktop visitors no longer scroll.
This trend is undoubtedly serious for the mainstream media. As we all know, newspaper sales have fallen dramatically in recent years, and the publishers of papers did, as a consequence, have to adapt with varying degrees of success to the creation of an online presence. The result has been that much of the media has survived, albeit with many fewer staff, and even lower levels of trust than they had before, as more and more news stories become simple regurgitations of press releases and stereotypical repetitions of political messaging, without questions being asked of those about whom reporting is being made.
As we now know, another trend has emerged, which I've also noted. The same source says:
At a time of ubiquitous content, there is a poverty of attention. Exhibit A: The Times cut its daily output from 200+ stories to 160, yet has seen four months of record traffic growth. Its sports desk cut output by 30% and traffic rose nearly 50%, while Hearst UK has also reduced article volumes and doubled traffic YoY.
I have particularly noticed this in reporting from the FT as well. The number of news stories referred to in the morning emails has reduced significantly over the summer, and they have developed an annoying habit of dragging in stories from previous days to add padding on occasion. The key issue is that content is changing and there is a rejection of information overload.
I am noting this, and as this autumn has begun, traffic is recovering. Traffic here is now running at around 20,000 a day, which is slightly down from a year ago, but it's more than compensated for by growing traffic on Substack, at nearly 5,000 a day, LinkedIn, at an average of 14,000 a day last week, and Facebook, where it seems the traffic is only a little lower than LinkedIn. Meanwhile, YouTube averages around 80,000 a day, with more than 50% of those viewing almost all of any video that we have to offer. I'm beginning to suspect that some mainstream media platforms might be jealous of these numbers.
What matters to me, though, is just what this downturn in viewing might mean, when I strongly suspect that it will be matched by declining viewing and listening figures for television and radio.
Firstly, at a time when AI is facilitating ever greater information overload, it appears that people are making it quite clear that they do not want this.
Secondly, if scrolling is becoming rarer, as anecdotal data also suggests to me, then much of social media is going to struggle right now.
Thirdly, there is an obvious risk that misinformation might increase as a consequence of this trend. I am not saying that the mainstream media is full of virtue because, as a matter of fact, it is misleading, but the risk is that the alternatives that people are now using are even more so.
Fourthly, and this is the most significant point, when an independent free press fails a country, its democracy is imperilled, and that is the risk that we are seeing here. People have now not only lost faith in their politicians, but they are losing faith in the media too, and the consequence is very dangerous. In such an environment, anything can happen, and that is the risk that we face.
Three questions follow.
First, will the mainstream media rise to the challenge and now present us with what people believe is reliable?
Second, would people believe it if it did?
Third, will those corrupt influences that have debased our media permit this?
I could, of course, add a final observation, which is that the organisation we should be able to rely on to rise above this is the BBC. The problem is that it has been as toxic as any organisation in its support for toxic racists, its prejudicial double-siding, which is anything but objective, and its total failure to hold politicians to account, which has been a significant contributor to the failure of its own reputation and that of politicians themselves.
So a fourth question might be, is a renewed BBC possible?
At present, I have no optimistic answer to any of these questions. That is what really worries me.
Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:
There are links to this blog's glossary in the above post that explain technical terms used in it. Follow them for more explanations.
You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.
And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:

Buy me a coffee!

The biggest gift the MSM can do for us right now is to help us to remember how we got to this situation.
One of the questions I wrestle with in omnibus discussions, is how to show that MY alt-media source is better than THEIR alt-media source.
Which one is fake news?
The only thing we have in common is a distrust of the BBC, such that we don’t watch/listen any more.
“I saw it on YouTube”. End of argument. Depressing.
Agreed
Obviously proper studies are needed to discover what’s going on, but here’s a couple of suggestions for (loosely related) factors. The first is the ongoing reduction in attention span. This is a well documented phenomenon (just put “falling attention span” into a search field) and a recent National Geographic article puts the average attention span at 40 seconds. That doesn’t get you very far into any medium that presents an argument that needs to be digested by the reader/listener/viewer. Not surprising if people avoid sources that take more than 40 seconds to read. This is terrible news in every respect.
The second is – ironically – the effect of AI. Despite generating slop by the lorry-load, it is really quite good at summarising information and presenting a concise overview. One consequence of this is that lots of sites are losing “clicks” from search results because the AI summary satisfies the immediate need. Clearly this also feeds into the attention span issue. Google have explicitly and consciously moved in this direction but other search engines (DuckDuckGo is my usual starting point) duplicate the behaviour. This is also terrible news in many respects.
Noted, and broadly agreed.
There will always be an audience of quality content. Where you find that content is changing and the manufactured MSM news agenda can overwhelm, by design.
AI summaries are changing how we are using online search. Traffic and clicks are down by maybe 25%. That’s hitting content producers who need organic traffic. As you note commercial publishers are reducing the quantity and quality of their output. We have a negative feedback loop.
Much B2B publishing has become live conferences and events or deep intelligence services, Very specialist High value. High price.
I’ve also observed that may younger people who grew up with digital consume very little traditional MSN and are falling out of of love with digital media of various sorts including gaming and the positively changing their behaviour. It’s got boring…margins ruling and ruining product quality.
Substack is a fascinating outlier. It’s the wild West of long-form journalism. Subversively chaotic and innovative. It gives me hope. Podcast are another area where creators have taken back control.
The decision the Government makes around BBC news and current affairs is one of critical cultural importance as it remains an important benchmark and reflects the role of the state . The bar has been allowed to fall so low it has lost authority and respect.
Thank you
I thought this story from yesterday, worrying…
https://pressgazette.co.uk/publishers/digital-journalism/facebook-algorithm-change-in-april-crushed-audience-reach-for-digitalbox/
Noted.
This is true for all the AI-generated search summaries that now do not require the searcher to go through to an actual site.
MSM is owned by corporate oligarchs/billionaire so no hope there.<p>
BBC hasn’t got a proper public service charter – its management are political appointments and as Tom Mills book says – it has never been a public service broadcaster – although maybe it was a bit better after WWII for some years<p>
Am more and more convinced our system – media and politics- is heavily policed by security services etc etc <p>
Paranoid
And look what’s happened to the Canary – debanked and, afaik, killed because powerful people don’t like the truth.
It’s just returned.
The BBC looks like a lost cause. Triggered by Evan Davis saying the government’s “chest is empty”, I complained that they continually breach impartiality with their constant peddling of household analogy-type narratives. I asked them why alternative perspectives on government finances are almost completely absent from their output. Ignoring the charge (or course!), they offered this interesting statement:
impartiality requires us to give due weight to significant viewpoints where they are relevant to the discussion
So, while they didn’t waste my time trying to claim they do cover alternative viewpoints, they did, accidentally, admit why they don’t.
Breaking it down a bit…
The BBC makes judgements on whether non-household analogy views are ‘significant and relevant’ to government finances.
If they are judged to be both, the BBC gives them ‘due weight’, which would mean at least a mention of them, surely?
Given that they are almost never even hinted at, the BBC must consider views other than household analogy-type to have neither significance nor relevance. What else can it mean?
It seems their own review into impartiality in their economic reporting (Blastland and Dilnot) is merely propping up the leg of a wobbly table in some conference room.
Never forget that Evan Davis was a Tory and an arch-neoliberal who wrote about such beliefs before joining the BBC.
Is it possible people feel burned out and are switching off?
Right wing MSM is a depressing catalogue of neoliberal harms without offering analysis, hope or resolution and so generates depression and despair. The only button to press in that situation is the off-button.
This is why FtF is so different. It offers hope.
I think it’s entirely possible that people feel burned out and are switching off. Don’t we all feel a bit like that on occasion?
And thanks for your kind comment – I appreciate it.
Part of their rebuttal was
“Evan Davis is an experienced journalist and former economist, with considerable knowledge and expertise in the field of economics”. Indeed.
They must have thought that the 20+ economists who complained in 2022 to the then Director General, Tim Davie (about Laura Kuenssberg’s “the government credit card is maxed out” garbage) must be know-nothing lightweights compared with Evan. Something she repeated almost verbatim two years after the impartiality review. Who are we to question ‘the talent’?
🙂
Might the actual and/or stated concerns about the B. B. C. lacking in objectivity and deep analysis, particularly in its “News” and news derivatives departments, plus its London/south of England centricity, iibe connected to its governing body only having representatives from two of the seven contemporary classes identified by the Great British Class Survey which are the Elite and the Established Middle Class?
Might members of the Elite and the Established Middle Class be those least likely to want objectivity and deep analysis of our society’s current political and socio-econmoic theories and practices?
(From AI Overview)
While I agree with the main points of your post Richard, your last point about the BBC is not fair. It needs pointing out that the last Tory government spent it’s time in power continually attacking the Beeb, reducing it’s licence fee income by over a third through below-inflation increases or fee freezes, both because they were sucking up to people like Murdoch who’s always hated it, and because an increasingly right wing Tory party dislikes public sector broadcasting as a matter of course. And now we see the licence fee itself threatened by increasing numbers of households not paying it, as they claim not to use terrestrial TV, although there is mismatch between people paying it and still listening to the Beeb.
The irony is that in an age of increasing algorithmic and AI based drivel (i.e. lies) there has never been more need for a trusted national broadcaster like BBC. Would those on here like RobertJ who say they no longer trust it prefer it to be entirely replaced by ‘news’ from the anti social media platforms used by far right thugs and lunatics like Musk? I get the feeling from the anti BBC posts here that some on the left are no more interested in listening to programs that don’t accord with their beliefs than the conspiracy theory far right are.
@Steve “Would those on here like RobertJ who say they no longer trust it prefer it to be entirely replaced by ‘news’ from the anti social media platforms used by far right thugs and lunatics like Musk?”
I listened to BBCR4 avidly from uni onwards – 1970s. As a farm vet I had it on all day in the car. Today, WATO, PM, World Tonight, Today in Parliament, + Newsnight if there was a good story, key live parliamentary debates, plus clinical Archers addiction 7.05-7.20pm, weekdays (went with the job – a sort of agricultural CPD). 1971 through to retirement 8 years ago.
To answer Steve’s question above – in a word, NO!
But that doesn’t make the neoliberal, Zionist, Unionist corruption of BBC any easier to cope with – apart from some dramas (no longer MADE by the BBC – because like government, they contract it all out), I haven’t listened to/watched BBC/News&Current Affairs (or any other radio/TV news channels) for about 5 years and I’m better informed now than I’ve ever been, by critically seeking out my own content.
Your challenge reminds me of those who regularly told me I had to vote for Labour Together’s LINO, to “save us from fascism”. No, I don’t and I won’t (2019 I campaigned for Labour, never again).
“Save the BBC!” is like “Stick with nurse for fear of something worse.” The “worse” is already here, and a corrupted, captured, controlled BBC won’t save us from billion dollar US financed and controlled granular algorithms on social media (and it is about DOLLAR$, as James Orr has so aptly and (allegedly) unlawfully demonstrated.
The BBC doesn’t listen to its licence-payers. It serves greedy/cowardly political bullying pimps, who give it a good slap, or worse, when it steps out of line.
Much to agree with. Thank you
Thanks for the comprehensive reply RobertJ. You are evidently a long time listener to the Beeb, as am I. I sometimes joke that I was brought up on R4, in the ‘morherhood and apple pie’ way. It’s still my main source,by far, of information about the world, particularly programs such as More or Less, In our Time, Farming Today, FOOC and so on. All these, and classics such as I’m Sorry l Haven’t a Clue’ justify the licence fee as far as I’m concerned. I’m currently recovering from a knee replacement operation and listening to a R3 day dedicated to Britain’s lighthouses.Superb. As regards news and current affairs coverage, l would like to know what you mean by a ‘corrupted, captured and controlled’ BBC?
It is the case that the funding cuts and an orchestrated anti BBC campaign by right wing media and politicians have affected it’s output (loads of repeats on R4 now). And KIT W-N makes an excellent point about the need for a DG prepared to stand up for the Beeb and the Reithian ideals it was founded on. I’m not using the hold onto nurse for fear of something worse argument here. I am saying that the Beeb is one of Britain’s great institutions, and there is more need for it now given the current mountain of lies and BS on social media.
I think that the BBC, though better than the alternative sources you suggest, has lost its objectivity and ability to challenge statements that are not based on facts. Outside politics and economics, BBC programmes and music are excellent. Perhaps the Full Fact charity should take over the running of news reporting on the BBC.
The BBC has gone down hill since I left in 2004 having joined in 1983 and (with tongue firmly in cheek) declared that I would one day make Director General (DG).
The only way to give it back some credibility would be to appoint an old-school investigative reporter as DG and give them free reign to kick arse. I’d vote for Kate Adie but she’d probably prefer to enjoy a well earned retirement.
Of course Richard would obviously make a good DG if he still refuses to run for PM. Experience running a business, understanding the accounts as well as experience making ‘broadcast’ content, a clear focus on what the Corporation should be and a skin thick enough to brush off the inevitable complaints from within and without.
PS One DG, can’t remember which, said that he wasn’t concerned about the BBC receiving complaints from politicians as long they received roughly equal numbers from both sides. It would only worry him if the complaints stopped coming.
We have a former boss of tax-avoiding Google instead.
BBC’s decline is longstanding. I noticed it in conjunction with the harmonized Western media narrative about Corbyn’s “antisemitism”, but about the same time it downgraded its international S/W broadcasting to almost nothing. BBC International had, I believe, to mind its claims because the audience was much less willing to take on faith news they knew to be bogus. Speculating here, but I do think the loss of international subject specialists hurt credibility.
More generally, downward trends in news consumption could be due to a number of causes and variations based on age and other demographics plays a part. My own experience is that MSM is widely useless – even critical reading can’t help it – while social media channels become overloaded with bots, trolls, state propaganda and junk to such an extent that engaging with it is pointless. Which leaves podcasters and substack. Real information is often there and usually identifiable. Craig Murray just filed a Russian report which even someone as cynical as I am find reliable and interesting. Richard’s blog is consistently informative even when contentious, and there are others who can be filtered to remove a declared bias. I have no problems finding credible data, but the placer mining approach doesn’t work.
Thank you
jorge,
If you want to know how to generate a million watts of wireless waves and direct it across the planet, I’m your man. Been there, done that, got the pension. But the audience for Short Wave radio has largely gone. I’m not sure how many of the 36 languages ‘we’ used to broadcast are now served up online but 40 years ago, whenever there was a loud bang and a flash of bright blue light at 3am in a building in the middle of a field in Cumbria I used to imagine an elderly gentleman in a turban, sitting on a bullock cart in warmer climes throwing his suddenly silent Tandy gheto blaster into the mud and shouting “F******g BBC!” as we ran to put out the fire, ventilate the smoke and replace the pieces that just weren’t there any more.
More seriously, it was John Birt and his ‘Producer Choice’ internal market that wrecked the BBC in the 1990s. He just couldn’t see that money paid by one department to another was a net cost of zero to the corporation overall and that paying a smaller fee to an outside supplier was NOT a saving. Programme makers found it ‘cheaper’ to buy a CD on the high street and bin it later than pay the world’s finest sound archive to retrieve the same recording for them to use. So, of course, the archive is no more. An organisation of clever people that was good at getting things done by knowing who to have a chat with in the canteen was turned into a disparate group of commercial service providers, just like the private sector, thus removing much of the justification for license fee funding.
Generally agree with Kit W-N, although my interest was not so much in the exciting mechanics of SSB S/W transmission and more in the loss of BBC International subject area specialists who actually knew their onions and could brief about reality on the coal face. Having said that, S/W may be an interesting area for private communications precisely because you can piggyback data on it and because ‘everyone knows’ that nobody listens to it any more.
[…] of unthinking nonsense even the FT can now produce, people's scepticism about the mainstream media, which I commented on yesterday, is entirely […]
It’s a given that the BBC is biased, in Scotland that bias is taken to an unbelievable level, it’s practically colonial on BBC radio Scotland.
Agreed
@sickoftaxdodgers
https://www.taxresearch.org.uk/Blog/2026/09/25/the-media-is-changing-and-that-threatens-democracy/#comment-1094463
“As regards news and current affairs coverage, l would like to know what you mean by a ‘corrupted, captured and controlled’ BBC?”
I would refer you to complaints by BBC staff about interference in their editorial decisions and journalistic reporting by management, and the clear political and ideological dominance in appointments right at the top of the BBC, the regular flouting of guidelines regarding impartiality on subjects as diverse as Israel, genocide, ethnic cleansing, climate change, protest, economics, references to the “household analogy”, Unionism, manipulation of programme audiences for Questiontime, coverage of Corbyn, use of terms like “extremist”, “terrorist” and “activist”, demotion or removal of certain presenters, the relentless promotion of Nigel Farage – I could go on a lot longer. There is so much evidence out there, the organistion is now effectively a propaganda arm of government. I remember a time when it took a more robustly critical line regarding those in power, precisely BECAUSE they were in power.
So I don’t waste my time with them any more, and I miss what the BBC used to be, but I don’t miss what they are now.
This is my final post in this thread.
A good summary. I’d add ‘general dumbing down’ of which the piggy bank economy is one instance. Thirty years ago I listened to R4 every morning and found it interesting if self-consciously clever. Now it seems almost self-consciously slow, as if the reading comprehension level had been ramped down in the style guide to accommodate a more doctrinaire approach. Perhaps misinformation needs to avoid nuance on the road to binary thinking? I agree about the increasingly political capture of senior management, a process that may have hit a watershed with the David Kelly coverage. It looked at the time as if a generally ‘hands off’ relationship between government and BBC became, after reporting on the ‘sexed-up dossier’, outright war, a scorched earth campaign launched by a furious Alastair Campbell.
Thanks for the reply RobertJ. You are partially correct regarding the political interference caused by Johnson appointing the Brexiter and pro-Israel right wing creep Robbie Gibb to the BBC Board. However, when I’ve heard Israeli government spokesmen being interviewed on Today they’ve not been given an easy ride. To be frank, on issues such as Gaza where opinions are so polarised, I think whatever the BBC does it will get criticised.
The real problem is that the BBC has been continually attacked and defunded by right wing politicians and their fellow travellers whilst those in charge of it have not stood up for it. That, and the decline in people paying the licence fee pose a threat to it’s existence. And that would be a disaster for democracy as all the public would be left with to inform it is right wing propaganda such as GB News and endless drivel on social media, most of it owned by American or Chinese organisations. We therefore need a trusted national broadcaster like the BBC to counter this. The problems you note re appointments at the top of the BBC need to be tackled, I agree. That’s possible, but it requires political will from our politicians. What is profoundly depressing is the relentless anti BBC attitude of the Tories and their allies and the spinelessness (so far) of successive DG’s, and Board members. I’d like to think this government would positively support the BBC and solve these problems, but I’m not too confident, since they seem to have rejected a lot of the funding methods suggested as replacements for the licence fee. Truly depressing.
Here in Australia the ABC funding was changed from a license fee to funding by central government decades ago. It’s still advert-free and nominally independent like the BBC.
Am I eagerly awaiting the outcome of the government green paper on media? No, but I am curious. After painting a cosy picture of families clustered round the box, the paper worryingly waffled on about directing people to ‘trusted sources’, as if tech companies have any interest in altering their algorithms to purely to please the government, said nothing about regulating internet content to remove that promoting hate and harm, and then turned to dates for 100% internet tv provision.
I don’t know the answer, but mainstream media is fairly recent, and has some unsavoury history, particularly between the world wars. Today the internet makes it much cheaper to distribute news and analysis than in the days when newspapers ruled, but is just as important that it is not monopolised. mElon man is probably a worse example of ‘power without responsibility’ than Lord Beaverbrook.
When governments, ISPs, and platforms WANT to regulate broadcast or internet content, including blocking, censoring, charging, surveilling, geo-restricting ,they CAN.
Issues not really technical but political, ethical and commercial. We, the people, are not consulted.
Examples:
Canary, minor historical code breach, regulated by Impress. (debanked twice, nearly bankrupted earlier.
GBNews – multiple Ofcom breaches, minimal enforcement – blatant contempt for “regulator”.
Jewish Chronicle – notorious for its adverse IPSO judgements – hand-wringing by regulator, “redeployment” of “creative” journalist, Lee Harpin and “polemical” former ed. Stephen Pollard, kept going with mysterious financial subsidy. Ask Robbie Gibb for further details (he won’t give them).
Great Red Firewall of China.
Comms blackout in Iran (including mysterious surge then blockage of Starlink during street protests/massacres).
N Korea. International isolation, internal control/state monopoly/surveillance.
Layer 7 DPI intercept of transatlantic internet traffic at Bude, Cornwall (ask BT).
Google, Yahoo and other providers of free email – DPI of email traffic content “for malware detection” purposes and advertising profiling and..??
Copyright restrictions, Pirate Bay/Bit Torrent traffic throttling (most ISPs), also DRM (Dgital Rights Management) for video & music.
Israel, IDF, Pegasus, root kits, no-click exploits, surveillance, blackouts, hacks, exploding pagers.
Police surveillance of social media for purposes of intimidatory arrest – occasionally, crime prevention (warranted bugging)..
IP blacklisting. Geolocation restrictions.
That scratches surface of what’s already going on, some legal, some illegal, some open, some covert. Your countries, and corporations you are customers of, are doing all this, NOW, for a variety of reasons, mostly covertly, occasionally for your benefit, but mostly not, and they often lie about it.
If a platform or politician tells you it isn’t possible to control what passes through their hands, they are lying, because they are already doing it (to suit their own purposes).
Very good point re Ofcom’s uselessness in holding GBNews to account for it’s multiple breaches of the broadcasting code. Given that GBNews is nothing more than a propaganda channel for Reform, why has it’s broadcasting licence not been revoked years ago?
And of course GBNews is owned by the far right hedge fund owner Paul Marshall who also owns the Spectator, Unherd, and other right wing rags. Another oligarchic media owner then.
Ofcom’s abject failure to enforce broadcasting regulations on GBNews should be a matter of utmost concern to this government.
I thought the green paper was pretty poor, and the gist of my response was: enforce standards, don’t herd people towards ‘trusted content’ as that could be abused and could capsize smaller providers of thoughtful content that does not violate standards on hate and harm.
Thank you
Just received this link to an interview with new BBC DG Matt Brittin. Having been skeptical of an ex-google ‘tech bro’ (which he says he isn’t) taking the chair I was very impressed and encouraged by this. I could work for this man.
I would not, ever. He is no friend of the bbc.
Oooops! The missing link is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b9zyYTCruUs