A new report from Global Financial Integrity finds that the drug trade is the single largest component, followed by counterfeiting:

WASHINGTON, DC – Illicit trade in “goods, guns, people, and natural resources” is a $650 billion enterprise, which most negatively impacts the developing world, finds a new report to be released by Global Financial Integrity Tuesday, February 8th. “Transnational Crime in the Developing World,” evaluates the overall size of criminal markets in 12 categories: drugs, humans, wildlife, counterfeit goods and currencies, human organs, small arms, diamonds and other gems, oil, timber, fish, art and cultural property, and gold.

“While this report includes a monetary measure of the cost of these illicit activities, it also stresses that the activities associated with these illicit markets‚Äîhuman rights abuses, corruption, murder‚Äî extract a significant toll on the lives of people in these developing countries and undermines economic growth and good governance efforts,” said report author Jeremy Haken.

Of the 12 illicit activities studied, trade in drugs ($320 billion per year) and counterfeiting ($250 billion per year) were ranked first and second in terms of illicit funds generated. Another key finding of the report was that profits from illicit markets are making their way to transnational crime syndicates through vast international trade networks. The report also emphasizes a link between transnational crime and economic “underdevelopment.”

Writes GFI director, Raymond Baker, in the report’s introduction:

The cross-border passage of criminal money is facilitated by the global shadow financial system comprising tax havens, secrecy jurisdictions, disguised corporations, anonymous trust accounts, fake foundations, trade mispricing, and money laundering techniques. This is precisely the same structure that enables the movement of the other two components of illicit proceeds—the corrupt and commercially tax evading money. We cannot succeed in curtailing part of these flows while at the same time facilitating other parts of these flows. The developing countries bear most of the burden of this facilitating global structure, producing impoverishment, violence, and shortened lives for millions of people across the world.

The report rankings for the illicit markets examined are:
1. Drugs $320 billion
2. Counterfeiting $250 billion
3. Humans $31.6 billion
4. Oil $10.8 billion
5. Wildlife $7.8 to $10 billion
6. Timber $7 billion
7. Fish $4.2 to $9.5 billion
8. Art and Cultural Property $3.4 to $6.3 billion
9. Gold $2.3 billion
10. Human Organs $614 million to $1.2 billion
11. Small Arms & Light Weapons $300 million to $1 billion
12. Diamonds & Colored Gemstones $860 million

The report is available for download here (PDF) or here.

 

As part of a newly announced government plan to tackle corruption, crime, and illicit capital flight, the government of India has joined the Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development’s Partnership Panel. Task Force Partnership Panel members also include the governments of Chile, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, the Netherlands, Norway, and Spain, the Canadian International Development Agency, and the Ford Foundation.

Tax Research LLP is a full member of the Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development along with Christian Aid, Global Financial Integrity, Tax Justice Network, Global Witness, EuroDad, Transparency International and Secretariat of the Leading Group on Innovative Financing for Development.

In a recent report, “Illicit Financial Flows from Developing Countries: 2000-2009,” lead Task Force member Global Financial Integrity (GFI) ranked India’s illicit outflows as the 15th largest among developing countries: approximately $104 billion, cumulative, from 2000-2008. Another report from GFI, “The Drivers and Dynamics of Illicit Financial Flows from India: 1948-2008,” estimated that India lost a total of $462 billion from 1948 to 2008.

A press release issued Tuesday morning by India’s Ministry of Finance stated:

The Government has formulated a five pronged strategy which consists of joining the global crusade against ‚Äòblack money’; creating an appropriate legislative framework; setting up institutions for dealing with illicit funds; developing systems for implementation and imparting skills to the manpower for effective action‚Ķ

India has joined the Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development in order to bring greater transparency and accountability in the financial system.

The Task Force advocates five recommendations for addressing the current global financial crisis, each one focusing on transparency and extending initiatives that have already begun to be put into place:

  1. Curtailment of mispricing in trade imports and exports;
  2. Country-by-country accounting of sales, profits, and taxes paid by multinational corporations;
  3. Require that the beneficial ownership of companies, trusts and foundations be readily available on public record;
  4. Automatic cross-border exchange of tax information on personal and business accounts; and
  5. Harmonization of predicate offenses under anti-money laundering laws across all Financial Action Task Force cooperating countries.

I’m delighted that India has recognised the importance of our work and the impact it might have on development by securing for that country the resources it needs to deliver the services its people need – services they are currently denied by tax avoidance and tax evasion through tax haven locations.

 

The Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development, of which Tax Research LLP is a coordinating committee member, is pleased to announce that Greece has become the newest member of the Task Force’s Partnership Panel.  Task Force Partnership Panel members include the Governments of Norway, Chile, Denmark, France, Germany, Spain, the Canadian International Development Agency, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Netherlands, and the Ford Foundation.

“We are pleased to welcome Greece to the Task Force Partnership Panel,” said Task Force Director, Raymond Baker.   “We look forward to working with Greece’s representative to the Panel, Mr. Ilias Plaskovistis, Secretary-General of the Ministry of Finance, on issues related to combating domestic tax issues and illicit financial flows.”

Launched in January 2009, the Task Force is a unique global coalition of civil society organizations and governments which advocates for greatly improved transparency and accountability in the global financial system.  Task Force membership is organized by the following component groups: Coordinating Committee,Partnership Panel, the Economist Advisory Council, and Allied Organizations.

The Task Force advocates five priorities in addressing the current global financial crisis, each one focusing on transparency and extending initiatives that have already begun to be put into place:

  • Curtailment of mispricing in trade imports and exports;
  • Country-by-country accounting of sales, profits, and taxes paid by multinational corporations;
  • Confirmation of beneficial ownership in all banking and securities accounts;
  • Automatic cross-border exchange of tax information on personal and business accounts; and
  • Harmonization of predicate offenses under anti-money laundering laws across all Financial Action Task Force cooperating countries.

The Partnership Panel mandate is to facilitate meetings with other government officials, provide information on discussions and conferences that are relevant to the Task Force, and strategize on how to best promote Task Force goals within governments, multilateral organizations, and other institutions.

 

It was good to be challenged about why we need much greater financial transparency to help developing countries by the IMF during an extended meeting with them on Friday.

The team from the Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development  was able to address these issues, and clearly make the case. A number of explanations were offered.

First, greater transparency in developing countries will be of benefit in those places. Without data markets cannot operate effectively. If you do not know with whom you are dealing; if you do not know how they are using resources; if you cannot be sure entities can meet the claims made against them; if you cannot even be sure how you can register that claim, then quite clearly there is a significant risk premium within those markets that increases the cost of capital in those places. There is also substantial risk of the misallocation of resources, reducing the rate of return on capital, which has the same effective consequence. That means the cost of doing business in developing counties is significantly increased without full and open disclosure of what all entities other than natural persons are undertaking in these places.

Second, the maintenance of effective systems of regulation to prevent bribery and corruption, crime and the abuse of tax systems through transfer mispricing is not and cannot be claimed to be an internal matter which developing countries alone can tackle. When there are states around the world – the 60 or more secrecy jurisdictions that we know exist – offer facilities that are deliberately designed to undermine the effectiveness of the law enforcement agencies in these places then quite clearly they face an almost insurmountable issue in tackling the problems they face internally with the scarce resources that they have available to them. This means solving the problem of illicit financial flows cannot and never will be a matter for the developing counties of the world to tackle in isolation, and individually.

Third, this problem of secrecy jurisdictions is  not a problem the developing countries of the world created. It is one we in the developed world created, and from which they suffer, along with us. We created the limited liability corporation. It has been useful, and nothing will now make it go away. But we also allowed it to be debased, to became opaque to the point we know little or nothing about most of the world’s corporations – even to the extent of not knowing where some of them are incorporated, or if they even exist on registers anywhere. We allowed that to happen. We provided the space for that to happen. We do at present continue to tolerate that happening. This is a problem we must tackle or law enforcement in developing countries (and our own) will be continually undermined.

Fourth, we have allowed the secrecy space that the combination of multinational corporation group accounts and secrecy jurisdictions in combination provide and which between them enable the whole process of transfer mispricing to occur – to far too great a degree undetected.

Without a doubt there is a problem of law enforcement in some developing countries. It would be entirely wrong to deny it. But to say that this is their problem to solve alone and that we have no duty to reform the requirements of the international financial system to improve its efficiency as a mechanism for allocating resources, for enforcing property rights, for preventing bribery and corruption , for preventing crime and for preventing tax abuse is just wrong.

 

A new report released today from Global Financial Integrity (GFI) on private, non-resident deposits in secrecy jurisdictions finds that the United States, United Kingdom, and the Cayman Islands are the most popular destinations for financial deposits by non-residents.   Switzerland, Luxembourg, and Hong Kong also make the top 10 list of destinations.

"This report looks at deposits held offshore by private entities on a country-by-country basis, achieving a level of specificity previously unavailable to the public," explained GFI director Raymond Baker.  "With overall deposits in secrecy jurisdictions currently approaching US$10 trillion, this report measures a sizable chunk of global wealth and helps us to better understand where individuals and corporations are putting their money."

Privately Held, Non-Resident Deposits in Secrecy Jurisdictions analyzes data from the Bank of International Settlements and the International Monetary Fund to measure total deposits by non-residents in areas considered secrecy jurisdictions under the definition established by the Tax Justice Network.

Notable report findings include:

  • Total Current total deposits by non-residents in offshore centers and secrecy jurisdictions are just under US$10 trillion;
  • The United States, the United Kingdom, and the Cayman Islands top the list of jurisdictions, with the United States out in front with more than US$2 trillion in non-resident, privately held deposits in the most recent quarter for which data are available (June 2009);
  • Contrary to expectations of perceived favorability for deposits, Asia accounts for only 6 percent of worldwide offshore deposits, although Hong Kong is the tenth most popular secrecy jurisdiction by deposits in this report;
  • The rate of growth of offshore deposits in secrecy jurisdictions has expanded at an average of 9 percent per annum since the early 1990s, significantly outpacing the rise of world wealth in the last decade. The gap between these two growth rates may be attributed to increases in illicit financial flows from developing countries and tax evasion by residents of developed countries.

The report also contains two case studies of Switzerland and Iceland, which show measurable fluctuations in financial deposits correlated to events in which financial secrecy or overall market solvency were threatened.

"This report shows that offshore deposits are on the rise, and the quantities of money being sent into these jurisdictions are massive," said Mr. Baker.  "The report also helps us to better understand where reporting may be improved to better differentiate between licit deposits and illicit deposits, which will ultimately enable better law enforcement in cases of tax evasion and other financial crimes."

Privately Held, Non-Resident Deposits in Secrecy Jurisdictions is the second report by GFI economist Ann Hollingshead.  Her earlier report, Implied Tax Revenue Loss from Trade Mispricing, was released last month.  Click here to download a copy of Privately Held, Non-Resident Deposits in Secrecy Jurisdictions, click here to download a copy of Implied Tax Revenue Loss from Trade Mispricing

Sep 182009
 

The following statement was issued by the Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development today following its two day conference at which I spoke:

WASHINGTON, D.C.-Today the Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development concluded a two-day conference which provided an opportunity to examine in-depth the linkage between global illicit financial flows and their adverse impact on development.

The massive flow of illicit money out of developing nations, estimated at some $1 trillion per year, outpaces current levels of foreign aid by a ratio of nearly 10 to 1.  Consisting of tax evasion, tax avoidance, and criminal and corrupt funds, this phenomenon is the most damaging economic condition hurting the global poor.

Therefore, the Task Force calls on the G-20 nations to recognize publicly that the flow of illicit money out of poor countries, facilitated by the global shadow financial system, cripples the ability of these countries to work their way out of poverty. Recognizing this linkage is a vital first step in creating the conditions to eradicate poverty in developing countries. The second step is taking action to stop these flows.

The Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development is a unique global coalition of civil society organizations and more than 50 governments working together to address inequalities in the financial system that penalize billions of people.

This, we believe, is a development imperative.

 

We are on the right side of history at the right time.

So said Raymond Baker in his opening conference comments this morning. And I agree with him.

The Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development is a unique global coalition of civil society organizations and more than 50 governments working together to address inequalities in the financial system that penalize billions of people. Launched by Global Financial Integrity in January 2009, the Task Force advocates for greatly improved transparency and accountability in the global financial system.

The Task Force advocates five priorities:

  • curtailment of mispricing in trade imports and exports;
  • country-by-country accounting of sales, profits, and taxes paid by multinational corporations;
  • confirmation of beneficial ownership in all banking and securities accounts;
  • automatic cross-border exchange of tax information; and
  • harmonization of predicate offenses under anti-money laundering laws – each one focusing on transparency.

This is the right time in history for each of these.

That’s what this conference is about.

 

Having spent two, successful days at the World Bank attention shifts a few blocks today to the 2009 Annual Conference of the Task Force on Financial Integrity and Economic Development will take place this week in Washington, DC (16th and 17th September 2009). Venue: Ambassador Room, Hilton Embassy Row Hotel.

I am delighted that Tax Research UK becomes a member of the Task Force in its own right this week. It’s a considerable honour to join the likes of Christian Aid, Global Witness, Transparency International, Tax Justice Network and others as members of this organisation that has one goal, which is to create a world financial system that delivers for the poorest on this globe. The work is backed by the Norwegian government.

The conference programme, below, shows the support this issue has generated and will highlight how a common approach to greater financial transparency can benefit rich and poor nations alike.

Speakers will address country-by-country reporting of income and tax paid by multinational corporations, listing beneficial ownership of subsidiaries, automatic exchange of tax information between governments, curtailing trade mispricing, harmonizing predicate crimes for money laundering charges among FATF countries, and other issues of transparency that continue to hamper development in poor nations. Among the list of leading experts slated to speak are U.S. Senator Carl Levin and scholars Dr. Francis Fukuyama and Dr. Paul Collier. Senator John Kerry is amongst the key notes speakers.
These are details of key sessions:

Panel 1 – Transfer Pricing
Alex Cobham
, Christian Aid, Chair
Jack Blum, Chairman, Tax Justice Network
Krishen Mehta, Director, Asia Initiatives
Raymond Baker, Director, Global Financial Integrity, Center for International Policy

Horizons 1 – Magnitudes and Directions
James Boyce, Director, Program on Development, Peacebuilding, and the Environment,
Political Economy Research Institute, & Professor, Department of Economics, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, Chair
Dev Kar, Lead Economist, Global Financial Integrity, Center for International Policy

Keynote – The Honorable John Kerry, United States Senator

Panel 2 – Automatic Exchange
John Christensen, Director, Tax Justice Network, Chair
David Spencer, Tax Justice Network
Martin Sullivan, Tax Analysts
Jonathan Winer, Senior Vice President, APCO Worldwide Inc

Horizons 2 – Norwegian Panel of Economists
Harald Tollan
, Norwegian Agency for Development Co-operation, Chair
Dr. Odd-Helge Fjeldstad, Research Director, Public Sector Reform, Chr. Michelsen Institute
Fridtjov Thorkildsen, Director, Governance and Anti-Corruption Unit, Norad

Panel 3 – Country-by-Country Reporting
Gavin Hayman, Campaigns Director, Global Witness, Chair
Richard Murphy, Tax Research LLP
Horacio Pe?±a, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP

Keynote – The Honorable Carl Levin, United States Senator

Francis Fukuyama, Bernard L. Schwartz Professor of International Political Economy & Director, International Development Program, The Paul H. Nitze
School of Advanced International Studies, Johns Hopkins University

Panel 4 – Beneficial Ownership
Charles Davidson, Publisher & CEO, The American Interest, Chair
Emery Kobor, Assistant Director, Strategic Policy Office of Terrorist Financing and Financial Crimes, US Department of the Treasury
James McDonald, President, Rockefeller & Co., Inc.
Anthea Lawson, Global Witness

Horizons 3 – Asset Recovery
Lord Daniel Brennan, Counsel, Matrix Chambers, Chair
Adrian Fozzard, Coordinator, STAR Project, World Bank
Alan Bacarese, Basel Institute
Ken Hurwitz, Anticorruption Senior Legal Officer, Open Society Institute

Keynote – Gayle Smith, Special Assistant to the President & Senior Director for Relief, Stabilization, and Reconstruction, National Security Council

Panel 5 – Predicate Offenses
Fran?ßois Valerian, Head of Private Sector Programs, Transparency International, Chair
Heather Lowe, Legal Counsel & Director of Government Affairs, Global Financial Integrity
Chip Poncy, Director, Office of Terrorist Financing & Financial Crimes, US Department of the Treasury
Nick Podsiadly, U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary

Horizons 4 – Economists’ Advisory Council
Paul Collier
, Director, Centre for the Study of African Economies, & Professor of Economics, Oxford University Department of Economics, Chair
Seeraj Mohamed, Director, Corporate Strategy and Industrial Development Research Programme (CSID), School of Economics and Business Sciences University of the Witwatersrand