Home > Blogging > Sad man of Christmas day

Sad man of Christmas day

December 27th, 2009

This award goes to Alex (who claims to be author of the Alex cartoon strips, but I very much doubt he is as I know those who do).

He wrote a comment on this blog on the Google tax story at 9.22pm on Christmas evening.

Normally I’d have deleted it as it was so obviously and absurdly wrong. But it was so sad I let it on.

Richard Murphy Blogging

  1. mike freeman
    December 28th, 2009 at 20:28 | #1

    steady on Richard , that’s a bit mean!
    Guy may be on an iron lung or something!

  2. December 28th, 2009 at 21:59 | #2

    Mike

    Others have tried to make this point but did so rudely and without an argument and so got deleted

    I have three responses. First I cannot be rude to a pseudonym. Alex is not a real person. He chooses to pretend to be other than he is. It is not my duty to worry about the person he might be.

    Second he certainly does not give the impression you suggest. He implies he is City familiar and highly competent. He gives no quarter. I feel no need to do so.

    Third, and most important for this was what I alluded to, the comment was sad because I think it represented the complete stranglehold economic rationality has over his life - reducing it to a shallow sadness that meant defending tax abuse from behind a veil of secrecy was more important than the reality and wonder of human life itself - as represented in Christmas day.

    If you think Scrooge was sad so was Alex’s comment

    Richard

Comments are closed.