If you want to submit a representation to the Treasury in advance of the Budget, you still have a few days to do so. The deadline is 10 September.
Submissions can be made through this website:
Mentions of the Taxing Wealth Report 2024 would be welcomed by me.
It is best that submissions focus on a particular issue and not be too long.
I was asked to suggest how such a representation should be written.
I admit I do not have time to prepare something myself, but this is from ChatGPT and is not bad:
Writing a representation to a government inquiry requires a clear, structured, and well-reasoned document that effectively communicates your views, concerns, or proposals on the matter being investigated. Here's a step-by-step guide to help you draft a formal and persuasive representation:
1. Understand the Inquiry
• Review the Terms of Reference: Understand the scope, objectives, and specific issues the inquiry is looking into.
• Know the Timeline: Be aware of submission deadlines and ensure your representation is timely.
• Research: Familiarize yourself with the background of the issue, relevant legislation, and existing government policies.2. Structure of the Representation
1. Cover Letter or Executive Summary (Optional but Recommended)
• Your Contact Information: Include your name, address, phone number, and email.
• Date: The date of submission.
• Subject Line: Mention the specific government inquiry you are addressing.
• Purpose: State the purpose of your representation and briefly outline the key points or recommendations.
• Call to Action: Politely request that your submission be considered and invite any follow-up if needed.2. Introduction
• Who You Are: Briefly introduce yourself or your organization. Explain your interest or stake in the inquiry.
• Why You're Writing: Clearly state why you are making a submission. This could be to provide evidence, express concerns, or suggest solutions.
• Summary of Position: Summarize your key points or the position you're advocating for (e.g., support, opposition, or recommendations).3. Background Information (Context)
• Facts & Evidence: Provide relevant background information on the issue you are addressing. Include factual data, research, or evidence to substantiate your points.
• Your Experience: If applicable, share your own experience or the experience of others that supports your position. This could include case studies, statistics, or real-life examples.
• Legislative Context: Refer to relevant laws, policies, or government actions related to the inquiry. Show that you understand the legal or regulatory framework.4. Main Body (Your Arguments)
• Key Issues: Identify the specific issues or areas the inquiry is concerned with. Address them one by one.
• Analysis: For each issue, present your analysis, provide evidence, and explain why you hold a particular viewpoint.
• Recommendations: Offer clear and actionable recommendations. These should be practical and relevant to the scope of the inquiry.
• Counter-Arguments: Address potential counter-arguments or concerns the government may have. Provide rebuttals where necessary.5. Conclusion
• Summary: Summarize the key points of your representation and restate your primary recommendations or conclusions.
• Thank You: Politely thank the committee or officials for considering your submission.
• Call to Action: You can close by offering to provide further information or to appear before the inquiry if required.6. Attachments (If Any)
• If you refer to reports, research, legal documents, or other sources, list them in an appendix or attach them to your submission.
3. Writing Tips
• Be Clear and Concise: Avoid unnecessary jargon. Keep your language professional and straightforward.
• Be Objective and Professional: While you may have strong feelings on the issue, avoid inflammatory or emotional language.
• Use Evidence: Wherever possible, back up your statements with facts, statistics, and relevant research.
• Keep It Structured: Use headings and subheadings to make the document easy to navigate. A well-organized representation is more likely to be taken seriously.4. Proofreading and Formatting
• Check for Clarity: Ensure that your arguments are easy to follow.
• Grammar and Spelling: Proofread carefully to avoid errors.
• Formatting: Use a readable font, standard formatting (1-inch margins, double or 1.5 line spacing), and number your pages if the document is long.5. Submission Process
• Follow the official procedure for submission, including adhering to any specific format or length guidelines provided by the inquiry.
• Submit through the correct channel (e.g., by email, online form, or postal mail).Sample Representation Outline:
[Your Name/Organization]
[Your Address]
[City, State, Zip Code]
[Email Address]
[Phone Number]
[Date]To: [Name of Inquiry or Official Title]
[Government Department/Agency]
[Address]
[City, State, Zip Code]Subject: Representation to the [Name of the Inquiry] on [Topic]
Dear [Chairperson/Committee Members],
I am writing to provide a formal submission to the [Name of Inquiry] regarding [specific topic/issue being investigated]. As [state your interest or expertise in the issue], I wish to contribute to the inquiry by addressing [outline key points].
Introduction
Briefly introduce yourself and explain why you are making this submission.
Background and Key Issues
Provide background information, including factual data or evidence, and identify the key issues related to the inquiry.
Analysis and Recommendations
Provide an in-depth analysis of the issues and offer clear, actionable recommendations.
Conclusion
Summarize your position and recommendations, and thank the inquiry for its consideration.
I appreciate your time and consideration of this submission. Should you require further information or clarification, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Title/Position if applicable]This format helps you present your case effectively to a government inquiry, ensuring your points are well-organized and impactful.
Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:
You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.
And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:
Would publishing some sort of guideline on how to make a presentation be a good idea. What do these people expect to see? What sort of format are they more likely to consider a serious proposal?
I have added a bit – you motivated me
Window dressing.
Does a so-called “representation to the Treasury” actually get read, examined and considered by whomever you are sending it to or is it just scanned, electronically filed, held for 5 years until it “expires” and is then deleted?
Moxt likely the latter, but I do know that some are looked at
Of course, there may be seection bias in what is looked at
If I thought that representation to the Treasury would make any difference whatsoever, they would not have it.
PSR is correct, it’s window dressing.
I made a submission last night, including a reference to the TWR. You get the option of submitting text (max. 250 words) or uploading a file. There’s also a list of different categories that your submission might fall under – I think you can tick as many as you like but I just went with Personal Tax. (I did try to post a link to this in a comment last night, but it seems to have disappeared into the ether for some reason.)
I got the impression it might be something the Treasury trot out regularly, as the blurb kept referring to “the Budget and/or Spending Review”, or more generically “the fiscal event”. Like PSR, I’m somewhat sceptical about it, but you never know. And for what it’s worth, a youth campaigning group called Green New Deal Rising have latched on to it and are urging their supporters to send in some copy/paste text they’ve put together. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NTBSa_JdPISUVu_ucnaR84QU9yL00gum1nsGPYgztw0/edit?b4968 So it’s possible the Treasury might find more in their inbox than they were expecting!
I’m sceptical as well but I banged the TWR in saying it proved austerity was not required, and highighted a few policy changes in the 250 words
Thanks
I’m doing it tomorrow. It’s going to be one simple proposal.
If an individual’s income exceeds £300k in the tax year then tax payable is simply income x 50%. No reliefs, no exemptions.
Income includes earned, unearned, capital gains and gifts/inheritance.
I probably ought to do this, but I’m not going to.
But thank you for bringing it to my attention, Richard. There are times when I would send my four penn’orth expecting it to be ignored, but send it anyway. This is not such a time.
I have real things to do in my own terms, and I realise that this IS a real thing in terms of what YOU do so I am not being dismissive in any way about the stupendous effort you make. Bt just now I can’t be bothered with it. Maybe another year I will feel differently. I have my work cut out persuading my wife she’s wrong without trying to convince Rachel Reeves who already knows she’s wrong.