Unless politicians mean what they say we get a world where nothing can be relied on and chaos rules. Trump's disdain for the truth is profoundly harmful in that case.
This is the audio version:
This is the transcript:
Words matter.
They clearly matter to me because, well, words are what I produce, right now, from me, into this microphone, looking down that camera, to reach you to discuss an issue that I think is of importance. And that issue is that I believe that words really do have an impact upon the world.
You will recall, perhaps from your childhood - I certainly do - that there was that horrible phrase that said, “Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me.”
It was stupid.
It was wrong.
It was utterly incorrect.
It showed a complete misunderstanding of human nature. Because words hurt very badly, very often. And we should be aware of that.
So why am I talking about this now? Well, I'm clearly talking about it in the context of our friend Donald Trump. I use the word friend loosely here, just to show how important words are.
And Donald Trump is saying things that Nigel Farage now says we shouldn't necessarily believe. He knows what he means, but we should interpret these things loosely because, well, he's Donald, isn't he? Rather like we used to say, ‘but he's Boris, isn't he?' of one of our former Prime Ministers, who turned out to be a complete idiot, and who was expelled from the House of Commons for not telling the truth.
And the truth matters. Because Donald Trump is either trying to deliberately mislead the world at present when he says things like Zelensky is a dictator in Ukraine when he clearly is not on the basis of absolutely straightforward factual observation, or he is simply lying.
But what he is definitely trying to do by making those claims is distort the reality that people understand about the world around them. And to me, that is a crime. That's a serious crime, because not telling the truth, deliberately distorting the truth, trying to gain an advantage by not telling the truth, it's akin to me, to fraud.
Fraud is the crime of securing an advantage by reason of a deception. And Donald Trump is committing a deception. And he's doing so to increase his electoral popularity and to advance his agenda in the USA. And therefore, my accusation that he is committing a crime is justified because there is no evidence that what he said is correct.
There's also no evidence that what Nigel Farage said is correct. After all, he said on the one hand, ‘I condemn what Trump says', and on the other hand, he says, well, he doesn't really mean what he says.
And therefore, he's not only hedging his bets, but he's also leaving us with doubt as to his meaning, and he's not alone.
Keir Starmer is at the present point in time planning for a visit to the USA about which Donald Trump has already said he does not know the purpose, because, as he put it, he's having the meeting because Keir Starmer asked for it, not because Donald Trump wanted it.
But Keir Starmer is preparing for that meeting by again using what I consider to be seriously duplicitous wordings. He and David Lammy, his foreign secretary, are both trying to keep Trump on side, whilst at the same time, phoning Zelensky in Ukraine to say, ‘No, we don't think you're a dictator.' whilst, at the same time, claiming the special relationship requires that they do get on with Trump.
I don't want Keir Starmer to get on with Trump.
I don't want David Lammy to get on with Marcus Rubio, or whoever it is who's the Secretary of State for Trump.
I don't trust those people. They do not tell the truth.
We cannot deal with people who lie with us. It is one of the most difficult things to deal with in life. When you realise that somebody who you thought you could trust is in fact a liar or has become a liar, you are completely disorientated as a consequence. It's happened to me in my life. I know how disabling it was.
And right now, that is what is happening in world political affairs. We expect the US president to tell the truth, or at least the truth as we would expect the US president to see it - which may not be something we necessarily agree with, but at least we understand the lens through which they're viewing the world, and therefore what we can expect from that perspective, and we therefore have a way of interpreting it.
But as it stands, we have a President who is not seeking to tell the truth.
He will make stuff up.
He will say it.
He will repeat it.
It is completely without foundation.
And in this sense, his only near rival in recent times has been Boris Johnson.
Again, I make that point. Boris Johnson did lose the confidence of his party. They literally decided in the end, by undertaking a mass resignation of ministers, as the only way in which to topple him, that he had to go. And go indeed he did, and he was eventually expelled from the House of Commons.
And the point is very simple. A liar cannot govern.
They can beat a country into submission, and that may be what Trump is trying to do. We don't know, but we all have to accept the possibility that he simply has given up on the democratic process in the USA, and will stay as he clearly intended to on 6th January 2021, whether he has an electoral mandate or not. But he can't govern on that basis, because at some point, people will have had enough of him.
If he stages a coup, there would have to be a coup to replace him in the end, because he literally will drive the people of the USA to a point of insanity, and he will drive the rest of the world to that point as well, because nobody will be able to trust a word he says.
Frankly, he's already reached that point.
Frankly, Elon Musk has already reached that point because very few people really believe what he says either.
And there is an enormous disquiet growing with these sycophants, with whom Trump is surrounding himself, who will say anything for the sake of it.
I noted his press secretary, joking as if it is a joke, that Canada is the 51st state of the USA. But it isn't. Canada. is an independent state, able to make up its own mind. The Press Secretary for the President of the USA can't present something that is not true and get away with it. They are creating misinformation, just as Trump is.
And this, therefore, is pernicious, because it's one thing for Trump to do this, but what he's doing is creating an environment where others feel free to do it as well.
What we know has ceased to be. What we know is now unknown, as far as they're concerned. And all we can do is fall back on wisdom. And wisdom is, for example in this case, represented by something that Maya Angelou, the amazing, great, black American writer once said, when she said, “When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time.”
And I think she was right. What she is saying in that phrase is, if somebody says something, trust that they mean it. They expose their deep inner meaning, their soul, if you like, as a consequence of what they say. And that is what Donald Trump is doing. He is telling us that he is reckless, a liar, indifferent to the truth, willing to be fraudulent, if you wish. And we should take him at his word. That is what Donald Trump is.
Now, the question is, what do we do about it? And there are two answers. One of the answers is that we tell the truth. I'm trying to do that right here, right now.
And the other one is that we search for what our meaning is. Here, I went back to look at a book by Viktor Frankl, who was a psychologist, who survived Auschwitz. He was in it, and he came out on the liberation. And he then wrote some amazing books about the meaning of life.
And what he understood as a consequence of that experience in Auschwitz was that when all else fails, the only thing left to us is to work out our inner meaning because nobody can take that away from us.
And this is where I think we have to be right now in the world. We have to work out what it is that in the face of this turmoil, this conflict, this dissembling, this deceit, this fraud, and everything else that is going on around us, what is it that we want? And my answer is that we want honesty, integrity, fairness, justice, well-being, the right of everybody to live well.
I believe that's what we want.
I believe that should be our meaning.
It's the exact opposite of where Trump is.
But my suggestion is, that this is a task that each of us can undertake individually. And if we do, in the face of this chaos, then we can come out with something better when it is all over. And indeed, more than that, by actually providing a counterforce to what Trump is doing with his lies and misinformation, we speed up the process of change towards that which is good.
Words matter.
I'm hoping that you've noticed what I've just said. I'm hoping they will make a difference for you. My goal is that we should use words to make a better world. And I believe that's possible.
Thanks for reading this post.
You can share this post on social media of your choice by clicking these icons:
There are links to this blog's glossary in the above post that explain technical terms used in it. Follow them for more explanations.
You can subscribe to this blog's daily email here.
And if you would like to support this blog you can, here:
He will make stuff up
He will say it.
He will repeat it.
It is completely without foundation.
He is telling us he is a reckless liar, indifferent to the truth, willing to be fraudulent.
Isn’t this exactly what you do, all the time?
You are correct about words.
There is a storm of words about: Trump, Russia and his cultivation since 1987 by the KGB and latterly the FSB. The broad outlines are out there (1987 private jet to Moscow @ invite of Russian ambassador, regular trip to Moscow, funding from Russian banks etc). In the case of Starmer and Lammy, this begs the question: what briefing have they had from MI6/SIS on Russia and Trump before their trip? Trump is a proven liar, year after year, decade after decade, his mini-me, Farage, is the same. Which leaves an open question: why is the UK media not questioning at least UK politicos more robustly? – with well formed questions, using well considered words.
I rather doubt that most UK citizens (like those of Ukraine) want to become an oblast of Russia, which appears to be the trajectoty that citizens of the USA seemed to have unwittingly chosen which leaves open questions regarding Farage, Deform and their talking points which are mostly, pro-Russian. Trump & the USA are developing into a threat to the UK, Farage and Deform are an enemy of the British people, their interest is mostly lining their own pockets (evidence? – Farage’s time as an MEP – what did he do for his Euro250k/yr?… nowt), their currency – lies, their political agenda – empty. So yes words do matter and it’s time the useless UK press deployed them with extreme prejudice targeted on Farage & Deform.
‘Why don’t the media question?’ – because public service broadcasters don’t do that -. They are part of the problem – they would no more ask about whether they have heard of the Trump/KGB history than they would ever ask questions about Labours corporate ‘donors’ ad what they might expect in return.
We are living in dystopia.
Absolutely correct!
Our own leaders should read this very carefully and think about what you have called their “inner meaning”.
When I look at our parliament, do I think we have 650 evil-hearted MPs? No.
When I look at the government benches, do I think we have 420 (I can’t keep up with who’s allowed to take the Labour whip so the number may be wrong) evil hearted Labour MPs? No.
When I look at the Cabinet and Shadow Cabinet do I think they are all evil-hearted? No.
I can’t judge the state of their hearts or souls, I don’t know WHY they behave the illogical way they do.
But there are times when we know that certain individual ACTIONS, certain collective DECISIONS, certain political POLICIES, are morally WRONG, and if we ignore that, if we go along with them, if we are complicit, even if we are silent, then we are threatening our own “inner meaning” – or as I might say, we are in danger of losing our souls.
I could now produce a substantial list of such wrong actions (we might disagree on whether one or two of them should be included or not) taken by our PM & Cabinet, and approved of by Labour MPs, which are WRONG – not unwise, or right-wing, or impractical, or stupid or untimely, but WRONG.
(a 4-5 year pattern of lying and deception by Keir Starmer would be top of my list, along with economic dogma that accelerates povert and gross inequality).
Whatever their apparent motivation, (fear, greed, ignorance, pragmatism) they are in danger, serious danger, of destroying their own “inner meaning”. Like “Dorian Gray”, if there is a portrait in their attic, it will begin to age, discolour, lose teeth and hair, no matter how cheerful they look as they cast their votes, or make their deceptive lying statements.
This is a very dangerous time for our PM, and Foreign Secretary. They have to decide about our so-called “special relationship” with the USA – is it more important than their own “inner meaning” (and the well being of our neighbours)? There is an interesting parallel with 1935 when Ernest Bevin, later to become Foreign Secretary, challenged others about our attitude to Fascist Italy and its invasion of Abyssinia.
I suggest David Lammy in particular, goes and has a look at the portraits of Lord Carrington and Robin Cook, in the FCO, then nips up to his attic and checks on his own portrait, then asks himself what HIS inner meaning is. Because after today, it will be too late. He will have destroyed it.
Narcissists habitually lie, mislead, and cheat. Conceit and deceit are some of the main tools in their toolbox. It allows them to gain control with those around them; those they want to manipulate. Narcissists are understood to have deep insecurities. Grandiose narcissists are assertive and extraverted, they are characterized by high self-esteem, a sense of personal superiority and entitlement, overconfidence, grandiosity, a willingness to exploit others for self-gain, and hostility and aggression when challenged. Trump has a severe personality disorder – is he really fit to be a president???
Ref: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0191886919305598
Agree re Trump, obviously.
Agree re Starmer: his wish to get on with Trump is misconceived.
I first read Farage’s assessment of Trump some weeks ago & it seemed useful because it warns us that the detail in Trump’s pronouncements is unreliable but he’s still a serious threat.
Agree re need for clear words. I work as an editor & indexer, so I must analyse authors’ meaning & try to get them to express it clearly. Unfortunately some politicians & academics seem only to speak to their own little circle.
‘We want honesty, integrity, fairness, justice, well-being, the right of everybody to live well.’
Agreed – the ‘we’ is important because otherwise its becomes an individual goal that can be exploited by authoritarians.
To which I would add : We want an end to corruption, and the purchasing of our democracy by unseen forces for their benefit and our dis-benefit.
Sticks and stones may break my bones but words will make me feel like I deserved it 🙁
Perhaps the most shocking (no longer surpising) and demoralising development with this MAGA autocracy is the corporate media’s misuse of words effectively whitewashing the fact that the most powerful leader in the world is a convicted felon and an adjudicated rapist. A heinous and dangerous political normalisation for all those who feel they have the right to indulge in sexualised violence and then blame their victims.