People don’t trust tax secrecy

Posted on

Christian Aid issued the following press release today:

The majority of Britons (57%) believe that company owners should not be allowed to keep their identities secret, with most (57%) saying they are suspicious of the owners’ motives where that is the case.

Key reasons cited by the public as to why a company owner would remain anonymous were tax avoidance and evasion (78%), to hide their true wealth (70%) and the hiding of criminal behaviour (59%).
78% think that company owners hide their identity to avoid or evade taxThe findings, in a new ComRes poll commissioned by Christian Aid, show feelings continue to run high about tax dodging two months after a G8 summit chaired by the UK Government promised measures to curb abuse.

The summit made some inroads, endorsing the principles of automatic exchange of information between tax authorities and limited country-by-country reporting by multinationals, as well as the setting up of registries of company owners.

In addition, a number of tax havens, including the UK Crown Dependencies of Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man, and British Overseas Territories such as Bermuda and the Cayman Islands, agreed to sign up to a key convention that would help identify instances of tax dodging.

With little evidence of progress since the G8, however, and concern that Prime Minister David Cameron is rethinking his own pledge to set up a public registry of ownership, public anger remains unabated.

More than half of those polled, some 58 per cent, agreed that a registry of ownership should be open to the public, as well as to tax and law enforcement authorities, including the police, both in the UK and abroad.

On the question of secrecy of ownership, only 23 per cent of respondents were aware that a UK company can be legally set up with anonymous owners, and only nine per cent said company owners had a right to such privacy.

Secrecy is often facilitated by tax havens, many of which allow ‘phantom’ companies to operate where the identity of the true (beneficial) owners remains completely hidden.
Beneficial ownershipSome 74 per cent of those polled say the UK government should now ‘force’ the Crown Dependencies and British Overseas Territories to make information about company ownership publicly available.

Christian Aid senior economic justice adviser Joseph Stead called on the UK Government to lead the way. ‘At the G8 the UK Government endorsed the principle of a register of individuals who control UK companies, for use by police and tax authorities. The Prime Minister wanted to go further and make it public. If he changes his mind now, he will undermine his own commitment to transparency,’ he said.

‘Our poll shows there is clear public demand for a register that is open to all. Business Secretary Vince Cable must resist the inevitable pressure from some businesses and tax lawyers against such a registry, and deal a fatal blow to corporate secrecy.

‘Phantom companies are like Russian dolls. Core ownership is disguised. That secrecy enables nameless criminals to evade tax, launder money and pay bribes safe in the knowledge that even the police will find it very difficult to trace them. This causes harm worldwide, not least in poor countries, which lose billions every year to tax evasion and corruption.

‘Often, the companies involved are shell companies, which only exist on paper and don’t have offices or staff. Instead, they are run by nominee directors who are just a front for the people really in charge.’

Mr Stead added: ‘As well as putting its own house in order, the Government must also ensure that the UK’s tax havens – the Crown Dependencies and Overseas Territories – follow suit with their own registers of who really owns what.  The British Virgin Islands alone hosts at least 400,000 companies, to say nothing of trusts and other legal entities.’

Christian Aid is calling on the public to email business secretary Vince Cable to ensure public registers are created which reveal who owns what, where, and for whose benefit at

84% are angry about multinational companies avoiding taxThe poll showed that overall, public opinion continues to harden against the tax strategies of multinationals. Some 84 per cent of those polled expressed anger at multinationals avoiding tax, up from 80 per cent in an earlier ComRes poll for Christian Aid in February this year.

Just over a third, 34 per cent, of people are still boycotting the products or services of a company because they do not pay their fair share of tax in the UK, the same percentage as in February, but many more people are considering such a boycott,  51 per cent, up from  45 per cent earlier this year.

Almost nine out of ten people, 87 per cent - up from 84 per cent in the previous poll - think that multinationals’ accounts should be more transparent and publicly available. And 83 per cent believe multinationals receive more lenient treatment from the taxman than individual tax payers, up from 80 per cent in February.

Some 90 per cent still think companies should pay tax in all the countries where they make a profit - a key reform which would help prevent present abuses where multinationals deprive developing countries of some US$160bn a year in lost tax revenues - while 86 per cent think it’s too easy for multinational companies in the UK to avoid paying tax, up from 85 per cent.