Home > Blogging > Comments

Comments

November 11th, 2009

I mentioned last week I was reviewing comment policy on this blog.

I have done so. Please see the new policy, which is here.

I just reviewed a batch of comments. 80% failed the new tests. They were deleted.

Think of it like writing to a newspaper: no paper guarantees to publish your letter if you do so. I reserve that same editorial freedom.

It will still be quite easy to get comments on here: but they must meet these criteria.

Richard Murphy Blogging

  1. John
    November 11th, 2009 at 16:58 | #1

    I’m pleased that most of the comments I make are published.
    I think that some I’ve made comply with the rules but haven’t been published, which is a shame.
    Its always interesting to read the blog entries, but sometimes I don’t understand some of the arguments, like the inference that PCCs are “bad” or facilitate money laundering; I genuinely would like to understand some of the rationale for these views, as I am sure would other readers of the blog.

  2. John
    November 12th, 2009 at 12:32 | #3

    Thanks for that link; a little one sided, and containing factual errors.
    It for example makes no mention of the use of PPC or SPCs for Collective Investment Schemes.

  3. David Drinkwater
    November 13th, 2009 at 17:22 | #4

    I wholeheartedly agree about both the Tobin-Tax and Cameron’s Hugo Young Lecture. I tried to get them discussed last night on BBC Question Time in Weston-super-Mare. I submitted questions on both issues in the hope that one would get selected. It was not to be, the BBC and/or the studio audience wanted to talk about the Sun’s publication of the PM’s letter to a grieving mother, immigration (it’s becoming a national phobia) and the MOD’s payment of bonuses to staff. A bit sad really - I was as bored in the audience as Wilf Self appeared to be on the panel.

Comments are closed.